Charles on a mission: Can king's state visit salvage US-UK ties? • FRANCE 24 English

FRANCE 24 English
Duration: 42:27 · 242 segments

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gi7xQW6jwZ4

[0:02]Call it the royal trump card. King Charles dispatched to Washington on a state visit at perhaps the lowest point in the special relationship in at least seven decades. We'll ask if catering to
[0:12]Donald Trump's enthusiasm for the British crown can dispel the bad blood over tariffs, the war in Iran, repeated jibes by the US president to make Canada
[0:22]the 51st state. Canada Commonwealth member whose head of state happens to be the same Charles III. invited to address Congress and fed it at a state dinner. Does the successor to Queen Elizabeth
[0:34]have what it takes to keep a poker face and stick to the script prepared by his prime minister? All it takes is a hot mic or a raised eyebrow for the media covering the 4-day visit to go into
[0:45]overdrive. Then, of course, there's the matter of the king's brother, the former Prince Andrew, who's been criminally indicted following the same Epstein files revelations that brought down UK ambassador to the United States Peter
[0:56]Mandelen. Coincidence of the calendar has Kier Starmer's ousted chief of staff testifying on the day back in London over the bungled vetting that led to the appointment of a former Labour Party
[1:08]insider whose nickname was the prince of darkness. Mandelson's reputation was no secret yet he was appointed anyways. Why? Well, to please Donald Trump. Today in the France 24 debate, we're talking
[1:18]about Charles on a mission with us. He's made the trip from London uh to New York. I guess you could say Tom Sykes is on a mission. European editor at large for the Daily Beast. Thanks for joining
[1:29]us. >> Thanks for having me. [snorts] >> Uh from Washington, Jim Townsen, former US Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for European and NATO policy. Good to
[1:39]see you. >> See you. >> Laura Carter, lecturer in British history at University Paris. Welcome back to the show. >> Good evening. Jeremy Stubs, deputy
[1:51]editor of the news site Kos, president of British Conservatives in Paris. How are you? >> Good to be here. >> Uh, you can reminder, always listen. That's right. Listen to the France 24
[2:01]debate wherever podcasts are streamed. I've always wanted to live in Buckingham Palace. Donald Trump adding three exclamation points to his post on Truth
[2:13]Social as he linked to a Daily Mail article that claims common ancestry uh with his guest on the day at the White
[2:22]House. Uh and a few drops of rain on the parade couldn't ahead of the state dinner and the king's speech uh didn't
[2:32]stop the president from uh addressing the crowds. Tom Sykes and uh uh Trump stating that his mother had a crush on
[2:42]Charles. Uh this isn't going off script in the wrong way. This is this is uh uh this is very much on message. >> Yeah. Welcome to the bizarro world of
[2:56]Donald Trump. Um it's been an extraordinary um kickoff to the state visit. I I think
[3:04]to be honest I think that the British royal family will feel that it's gone very well. I think that the administration will feel it's gone very
[3:14]well and it is a very very important moment for everybody involved because the UK and the US the relationship is
[3:24]incredibly strained and if there is one person who can fix it it is King Charles the Trump whisperer himself. So, let's hope he can pull something out of the bag.
[3:34]>> Trump whisperer himself. Uh, wasn't Kier Starmer supposed to be the Trump whisperer? >> I think anyone who can have a sort of conversation with Donald Trump for more
[3:45]than about five minutes is instantly called the Trump whisperer because we're so desperate to find anyone who can talk some sense into the man. But I I do
[3:56]look, I am a great believer in Charles. I think that he is being brave and courageous as he's dealt with his cancer. I don't think that it, you know,
[4:06]he is, Donald Trump is not the kind of person that he would naturally want to hang out with. And he is doing his best here to look delighted, to be smiling,
[4:17]to be happy. He's doing exactly what the head of state is supposed to do, and I take my hats off to him. >> Yeah. and uh the press kept at bay uh
[4:27]you're for a lot of the uh White House visit. Um earlier at the UK Embassy Garden Party, the guests included the same speaker of of the House, Mike
[4:37]Johnson, who will be introducing uh the uh uh king uh for that joint uh session of Congress speech. Uh Johnson,
[4:46]who back in January addressed the House of Commons. Uh Tom Sykes again. Will everything go to form uh before uh uh
[4:56]the lawmakers in Congress? >> Yeah. So, we're told that Charles has had some input into this speech himself,
[5:06]which is a little unusual. Usually, a speech like this would just be written by the government because I mean, fundamentally Charles is there at the request of the British government, right? He's not there on his own
[5:17]initiative. We have been told that the speech is going to contain the word reconciliation. I mean, we're going to find out in in just over an hour's time, 3 p.m. local time, he's going to be
[5:28]making this speech. Uh, of course, there could be no more King Charles word than reconciliation. There could be no more non Donald Trump word than
[5:38]reconciliation. Um, so I I think that's the attempt to plausibly with with plausible deniability to attempt to say that the
[5:49]king is, you know, standing up somewhat to Donald Trump, that he's not getting it all his own way and that we are putting our case that, you know, people
[5:58]need to uh maybe stop bombing the hell out of each other and try and start talking to find some solutions around the world. Jeremy Stubs, this king has had to, you know, he he he he often has
[6:09]delicate assignments, uh, going to former colonies, uh, and the such. Is this his most fraught mission?
[6:20]Yes, I I think it is, and I have no doubt that he will do a fantastic job while he is there. But the government has already played the royalty card
[6:29]once. Karmama delivered that invitation in the Oval Office in February last year. and the visit by uh President Trump was made in September. That sort
[6:40]of smooth things over for the first phase. We're now, as you said before, in an even more difficult situation. Charles will no doubt do a, as I say, a
[6:49]very good job, especially as this is a particular occasion. This is celebrating 250 years of American independence. So it really is a moment for the two
[7:00]nations to come together and reaffirm their friendship. The trouble is problem is the the elephant or gorilla in the
[7:08]room is the state of British armed forces. I know that doesn't sound very sexy or very royal but that is the real the fundamental problem which I'm sure
[7:18]will not be talked about thankfully. >> The state of British armed forces or their refusal to take part in the Iran war. The two obviously overlap, but the
[7:29]thing is that even if we wanted to take part in any war, I don't think at the moment we're in much of a state to do so. And the Trump administration has
[7:39]already said that the model ally of the United States is Israel and not Britain. It's not that we're out completely, but we are very much down in the pecking
[7:49]order. It's also the UK uh current UK ambassador to the United States uh who said that off the record and it was picked up uh Laura Carter. So not so
[8:01]special relationship. Your your your thoughts on this? Is this just a you know a bit of ceremony? And is and is uh Jeremy Stubs right to worry
[8:11]that maybe they've played the crown card a little too often? I see the point, but I wonder if when you've got a royalist like Trump in the Oval Office, whether the Crown Card isn't one you keep
[8:21]playing because clearly he likes to be associated with the royal family. He >> he's a royalist, you're saying? >> I think so. Yeah, he he's much more a royalist than he is a fan of the British Labor Party, put it that way. So, you
[8:32]know, he's um he's someone who likes that association. He likes the pageantry. So, it's the the hardest soft power card Britain has while Trump's in office. And I think they'll probably
[8:43]keep playing it until it's uh dropped on the floor. Um but I think um at the same time, you know, he's from the king's point of view, he's starting or he is
[8:54]making his mark out of his mother's shadow and there are kind of historical precedents for her celebrating the 200 200th anniversary of the um war of independence in 1976 and giving quite a
[9:05]pointed speech. So I think there are those historical parallels too to draw. there's very much a place for him at this moment, even though things are much more fraught between the US and Britain than they were then.
[9:16]>> Yeah. Uh they were the last time a British monarch addressed Congress, it was 1991, Gulf War I, the United States had rallied 41 nations, including the UK
[9:26]and France in a coalition to chase Saddam Hussein's invading Iraqi forces from Kuwait. [applause] Some people believe that power grows
[9:38]from the barrel of a gun. So it can. But history shows that it
[9:45]never grows well nor for very long. Force in the end is sterile. [clears throat]
[9:54]We have gone a better way. Our societies rest on mutual agreement, on contract, and on consensus.
[10:04]>> So, Jim Townsen, what would happen if the Queen's, the late Queen's son, uh, were to just do a copy paste of that
[10:14]clip you just heard? >> Well, I think it'd be a bit of a loss opportunity. Uh I I think what she said was great and I think particularly back
[10:24]then it made a lot of sense and was welcomed but I think there's other things that the uh king should point to and talk about uh in terms of what's happening uh in the transatlantic
[10:35]relationship and uh uh what we're seeing in uh particularly in Europe dealing with Russia Ukraine. I don't think he would get into specifics like that, but there's bigger broader trends going on
[10:46]that uh he might want to talk about a bit more than just do cut and paste. >> And do you take Jeremy Stubs's point that uh one of the problems for Britain
[10:56]is that its military uh ain't what it used to be? >> I absolutely do and I was very glad to hear him say that. And just to make the point, you know, the special
[11:06]relationship is uh it's it's a pretty broad and deep relationship. I I worked with that in the Pentagon for years. I worked closely with the UK and I really
[11:17]feel right now the strain in the relationship is really a personal one between Trump and uh Kier Starmer and and maybe some of Trump's uh his associates there in the White House.
[11:28]what they might feel in terms of how they misread the European uh allies including the UK about Iran and began to this this tussle. So that's really to me
[11:40]that's not the special relationship on the rocks. I think the special relationship is is pretty hardy quite frankly. But the point about the military capability of the UK and where
[11:50]they are now and efforts being made or not made to try to correct things, that is really for the professionals, if you will, for us in Washington who are watching the relationship, that is
[12:01]something of great concern to us. Uh, and watching how the UK deals with that and tries to fix it, uh, is what we're really more concerned about than anything else. the UK ambassador to the
[12:12]US uh reminded uh um one of the Sunday talk shows uh that uh the intelligence sharing continues despite uh the uh the
[12:24]heated rhetoric at times. But how for how long under the current circumstances? >> Well, that's an important point. The intelligence relationship is uh part of
[12:35]that special relationship, too. Uh it's a bit of a the core part of it. There's a lot of things that the US and the UK do on the intel side uh that we don't do with anyone else and there's a lot of
[12:47]trust there between the professionals in those uh in the intelligence community here and also in in the UK. Um I I think there is concern at the professional
[12:57]level uh as far as sharing information that Trump might accidentally release uh you know in a Oval Office discussion or something like that. So I think in terms
[13:08]of sharing between the two there is some second thought being given about should we really give this to Washington or hold it back for better times. Uh so so there is that concern but at the end of
[13:19]the day that special relationship between the two intelligence uh portions of the governments is very strong and it will continue. >> Yeah we heard a variant on that doubt
[13:29]over whether to trust the United States uh posited by the Polish prime minister last week. Now, even in the buildup to the king's visit, the threats continue,
[13:40]including the rekindling of resentment over the UK's claim to the Faulland Islands, which it took back from Argentina in a 1982 war. The Reuters news agency last week pointed to a
[13:51]leaked Pentagon memo that threatens to kick Spain out of NATO. Uh, and uh, the memo also includes an option to consider reassessing US diplomatic support for
[14:02]long-standing European imperial possessions such as the Faulland Islands near Argentina. Now, Tom Sykes, this
[14:10]isn't uh Trump needling uh, the Labor Prime Minister. This is a a leaked Pentagon memo. How concerned should the
[14:21]British be? There's an old saying, isn't it? I can't remember which way around it is. Don't take Trump literally, but take him
[14:31]seriously. Is it the other way around? I can't remember. But I think the point is is that I think people are well able to distinguish between, you know, the saber
[14:41]rattling that's going on and the fundamental common shared interests of our countries of the United States and the United Kingdom. We are chums. We are
[14:51]on the same side. We have to get through this. Trump is, you know, a divisive figure. He has his own way of going about things. But that's what the king
[15:01]is there for. The king is there to pour oil on troubled waters. And I for one hope that he can do a really good job. And if anyone can get through to Trump,
[15:12]he deserves our congratulations and thanks. Uh in the buildup to the speech before Congress, we had a California Democratic congressman by the name of Ro Kana uh who pressed the king to meet
[15:23]with Epstein survivors. The British monarchy uh can be seen as a relic of colonialism and imperialism or it can be a modern force for standing up for
[15:34]women's rights and human rights. I hope he will reconsider uh said that uh uh congressman. No such uh uh event uh I is
[15:45]planned uh uh Tom Sykes uh but with the king's brother uh being stripped of his royal title and under criminal
[15:54]investigation. How much of Epstein is already coming up in conversation where you are? Do
[16:04]>> you know I I just think Ro Cana I think this is I think it's so childish of him to put this on social media. I think it's so counterproductive and so divisive. Like the idea that this is
[16:15]just like some visit to the United States and the king can just branch off and do what he likes. Like this is not the king didn't wake up one morning and decide to go to America. This has been
[16:25]organized for months if not years. This is like you can't just suddenly decide that you're going to go and like do X Y and Z. Oh, I'm going to go and meet Harry and Megan. I'm going to go and you know meet with these people. Not saying
[16:37]that the Epste but the king has done a lot about the Epstein scandal. He has removed his brother's titles. He has told the police to investigate him. You
[16:47]know, the United Kingdom, to be fair, has done a hell of a lot more than the United States has done. Why doesn't Roana have a go at people in his own country? Quite frankly, I think it's I
[16:56]think it's childish of Roana. Uh the Epstein files, uh you have a US president, uh Jeremy Stubs, who's not
[17:05]been directly implicated himself so far. Same with the king, but they're indirectly tainted by it. >> Well, I think everybody will be avoiding
[17:16]discussions of that uh during this visit. Um it is true that Queen Camila for example will be talking to women
[17:24]about the uh abuse that they often suffer. It won't be about the Epstein victims in particular but she's showing as she often does this particular
[17:35]concern and I think that is as much as can be done in these particular circumstances. But the uh the whole thing really is
[17:46]that uh the king being there it's to play on those subjects and I don't mean that in a political sense on those
[17:55]themes which enthuse Americans generally about Britain and the royal family. That's what they're there to do. They're there to be seen. the king I'm sure will
[18:05]make a very well um couched diplomatic speech and there is a common celebration of
[18:14]history as I said before since 1776 and and that is a tremendously important thing I mean people's eyes and I include
[18:24]President Trump in this will be on as it were the great longlasting things rather than on particular details at this time >> Laura Carter the is Is this kind of the
[18:35]elephant in the room though? It won't be discussed. >> I think [clears throat] Epste is the thread that holds all of this together, right? It links Mandlesson, Andrew Mbatton, Windsor, and and Trump, and to some extent the king. I I I doubt it
[18:46]will be discussed. I think it's a shame that Queen Camila isn't meeting survivors. Epstein survivors. The lawyers have have actively asked for that, but the circumstances are as such that she's meeting other abuse
[18:57]survivors. She, you know, I was just thinking about the the tweet from Roana that you that you showed that presented the two options. You know, the monarchy is either a relic of imperialism or, you know, something that stands up for kind
[19:08]of uh women's rights and all these modern values. But I think the whole point about the modern monarchy is it's it's it has to be all those things at once. I mean, it's the king or the monarchy is always reticent about making
[19:19]historical apologies around imperialism and colonialism and is trying to, you know, through um Prince William and uh go ahead with topics like mental
[19:29]health and also women's rights. So I think all these things are always trying to be held all at once within the modern monarchy. There's no there's no uh shaking off the the the colonial
[19:40]history. I mean it's impossible. >> Yeah. And we're seeing images of uh delegations arriving for that speech before that joint session of Congress. You're getting to the heart of the
[19:50]matter here. How much of this is the king's decision on the messaging on something like the Epstein files and how much of it is uh down to the prime minister? >> Well, I'm sure it's a lot of it's down
[20:02]to the prime minister, right? We've heard that the tone is going to be from the king and the speech, but the content is no doubt from the you know shaped and formed by the government. Um I think on Epstein, you know, clearly there's many thing I mean I imagine there's nothing
[20:14]the king wants to talk about less than that topic. Um, but given that Camila has made specifically uh survivors of sexual abuse one of her her topics and
[20:24]and women's rights and women's safety, I do think it's a shame that that that hasn't been able to somehow be worked in for for the survivors themselves and for, you know, for women more generally.
[20:34]>> All right. And while you have the red carpet rolled out in Washington, over in London, the opposition conservatives this Tuesday calling for a parliamentary inquiry into StarMR's handling of the
[20:46]Mandlesen affair. It's unlikely that enough Labor MPs would break ranks and agree to refer the matter to the Commons Privileges Committee, but there was meanwhile uh testimony heard this
[20:57]earlier in the day. Parliament's foreign affairs committee hearing from the mastermind of Kier Starmer's winning election campaign in 2024. Morgan Mweeny resigned in February. Fresh allegations
[21:08]came to light that purport [clears throat] to show that Peter Mandles passed sensitive information to Jeffrey Epstein in 2009 when he was Gordon Brown's in Gordon Brown's
[21:18]cabinet. Mick Sweeney stating regrets that he made a serious mistake when he recommended Matt as ambassador to the US in 2024. clear. >> I thought he was the right choice uh
[21:29]after the US presidential election. Um the reason why I thought he was the right choice is because Britain was exposed, the UK was exposed after Brexit. We left the European Union
[21:40]without any US trade deal. And for me, honestly, this was the top priority of the prime minister was to uh get a US trade deal with the Americans. And I thought that based on Mandlesson's
[21:51]experience as an EU trade commissioner, that made him the strongest candidate. But like everybody else, I uh made clear to the prime minister there was pros and cons and and and and there was there was
[22:01]risks. >> Jim Townsen, that clip uh does it sum up a bit why King Charles is
[22:11]in the United States as well, a country that wants to do the right thing but has no other choice than to cozy up uh to a
[22:21]leader it doesn't agree with on a lot of matters. Well, I think we I think uh we all want to do the right thing at the end of the day, but I think I think in terms of uh
[22:33]that the clip and the the visit, there's a time and a place for everything. And I think right now, as many of your colleagues just said, uh right now isn't necessarily the right timing to do
[22:44]something along those lines. There's a lot of other work that's got to be done on both sides of the Atlantic cons. And I think there will come a time when there could be a uh you know reaching
[22:55]out to the survivors in such a manner as as was described. But I don't think that time is during this visit. >> The time's not during this visit. Tom
[23:03]Sykes perhaps. But it is amazing how Jeffrey Epstein has uh inflicted so much political damage on both sides of the
[23:13]Atlantic >> moment. At the same time, uh, the Epstein scandal is the black hole of
[23:25]scandals. It just keeps growing. It keeps sucking more and more people in. But I do wish, honestly, that rather than, you know, this grandstanding about
[23:36]Charles, should he do this, should he do that, when he just can't. He's constrained. He's the constitutional monarch. He's the leader of the country. I do wish the Americans would get their own house in order frankly and take some
[23:47]action against some of the pe you know many many many men who are mentioned in the Epstein files in America who have not faced any consequences at all unlike what's happened in my own country.
[23:59]>> Well Tom Sykes it's interesting because you're in you're in the United States uh just 3 days after uh an alleged attempt
[24:08]on the the US president's life. Uh part of the discussion has been over whether there was a conspiracy and here you have an actual conspiracy. I mean this is the
[24:19]definition of a conspiracy is it not? Uh Jeffrey Epstein uh getting intel before the public can uh for insider trading
[24:28]purposes at times to lobby politically uh and and and and parlaying in it uh uh praying upon young women.
[24:39]Is that irony lost? >> It's such an extraordinary story. And don't forget something that people often forget is that Peter Mandelson was a
[24:51]great advisor to King Charles. Um when Charles was trying to rehabilitate himself in the sort of project queen Camila years when immediately after the
[25:00]death of Diana and Mandlesson was this figure who'd rehabilitated the Labour Party. Charles was a great Madison was a great confidant of chances. He was the
[25:11]recipient of the late night phone calls. He'd be invited to Sandringham for these weekends with artists and poets to brainstorm the future of the monarchy. So, I mean, it is incredible how the
[25:21]Epstein scandal continues to metastasize and to suck in so many people. It it is a problem for the king. There's no denying it's a problem for the king that
[25:31]his brother was um part of the Epstein circle. It's a problem for the king that the king contributed $2 million towards the settlement to Virginia Du Fray. Um
[25:42]it was basically a gagging uh settlement of Virginia Duay. Um it's a problem that he was all over that. It's the photograph that you're showing in your screen of of Andrew at the famous
[25:52]ballroom at Sandringham. You know, it's all a massive problem for the king. The the the question is what did the king know and when did he know it? Um but I I
[26:02]do genuinely think that it's a question for another day. >> But it is on this day when uh we saw more heat being poured on on the prime
[26:14]minister, not on the king, but on the prime minister, Jeremy Stubs. And and again, it's uh in this case, it's not about the Epstein files directly, but
[26:24]it's about the vetting and naming of that ambassador to the United States, Peter Mandel. uh we uh have been talking
[26:33]about it. Uh they say that the prime minister uh will be able to hang on at least until uh local elections take
[26:43]place next month. Uh but again, your thoughts when you see how it's playing out right now in parliament? Well, it seems like the script of a Netflix
[26:54]series. And you can imagine the montage between scenes of the king in very dignified situations in the United States and scenes of the
[27:06]uh testimony given by uh these two former uh associates, employees of of um Karma. And the fact is that King Charles
[27:18]is in the United States to save Britain's bacon as it were, but not Karma's because Karma from what we're
[27:27]hearing day after day is I think as you said uh Frantois is likely to be ejected after the elections. >> We've just got breaking news. He's averted uh this parliamentary inquiry.
[27:38]That's not going to happen. No, we knew that would not happen because Labour MPs need him to stay there and take the
[27:47]flack of the probable disaster in May and afterwards then the vultures who are quietly circling at the moment will
[27:59]swoop in and pounce and he will be out. So if there is a palace coup, Laura Carter, does uh
[28:07]all this the this stain of the of of the Epstein files go away for the British government? >> Oh, no. I don't think there's really anything that can happen in the US visit that's going to change what's going on
[28:18]domestically now for Star. Um I think that it depend it depends really what happens internally in the Labour party and with his colleagues and what we see
[28:28]in May and how far reform manages to take seats away from the Labour party because those are the kind of broader contours of domestic British politics recently. Um, so no, I mean the stories
[28:39]are I think linked by Epstein, but I think um the US royal visit needs to just go off smoothly and they will perhaps have smooth things over and avoided that. But I think Kisam has got
[28:50]problems at home that aren't that aren't getting fixed. >> All right, whoever the UK prime minister is, uh there's again still the question of how to handle a Donald Trump who is
[29:01]not going away next month, uh who has [clears throat] a thousand days in office left. Uh Kier Starmer, not the first UK prime minister to flatter a US president. Remember the Yo Blair
[29:12]incident at the 2006 G8 summit in St. Petersburg, Russia in a hot mic? Uh Tony Blair, who critics called Poodle at the time, seen bending over to brief George
[29:23]W. Bush while the latter keeps chewing on his lunch. When Kier Starmer was invited to the White House, one month into Donald Trump's uh uh second term
[29:33][clears throat] last year, he made a big show of extending that formal invitation to visit the king in Britain before the cameras in the Oval Office. The optics
[29:44]don't always play in Star's favor like at last June's G7 summit in Canada. >> Okay, thank you very much. which uh we all know the great prime minister of the
[29:56]UK and we just signed a document. This is sorry about that. >> Is it >> a very important document? [clears throat]
[30:07]>> Ah Jim Towns play political strategist for us. Should he have picked up those pieces of paper? >> Yes, because everyone needs to be polite to one another. I think that's uh that
[30:19]would have that would have been a good move. But I think I think the days of flattery uh that they're over now in terms of how Europe uh including the UK uh has to deal with Trump. I think
[30:30]that's uh that's beginning to cause more problems and fix them. >> So hang on a second. So what you're saying is is that the images we saw in
[30:38]February of 2025, a year ago, of Starr handing the invitation to Trump, there was a lot of flattery in his remarks at the time. That was okay then, but not
[30:49]now. But not now. I think what's happened is uh uh flattery is going to be seen as weakness by Trump now. I think uh I
[31:00]think that was a tactic that was useful in the first term up to a point. Uh I think it's been useful maybe in the first couple of months of this second term. I think with Mark Ruta, he might
[31:10]have taken it a bit a bit far in terms of working Trump. I think now the way Stu uh from Finland uh President Stub handles Trump you know business-like
[31:20]matterof fact um you know getting along um just on a business basis. I think that's really the the approach now that works the best. I think the Feds are leading the charge in terms of being a
[31:32]real Trump whisperer >> and they're on the front line of course sharing that border with Russia. Uh Jim Townsen, uh again, what do you put in the king's speech that would get through
[31:44]to Donald Trump on on when it comes to Ukraine and Russia? >> It's a very interesting question. It's
[31:53]it's this idea of do you have anything like that in um in the King's speech at all? Does he really get into these hard questions uh in a public venue,
[32:04]particularly in front of the Congress, or do you stay above that? you talk about our shared values, etc. Um, and I think if you do, if you want to have him talk about Russia and Ukraine um, I
[32:16]think he should probably use a light touch, but but just make sure he makes the point that uh, the Russia we're dealing with right now is a one that we
[32:25]have got to be very careful with, concerned about, and that we've got to particularly give strong support to Ukraine. if he can say that in a way that isn't pointing the finger at Trump.
[32:37]But I think that's an important point for him to make in a kingly fashion. Uh where he talks about what is important for not just the UK uh and not just for Europe, but for the United States as
[32:49]well. >> Yeah, it's a it's a bit of arbitration, Tom Sykes, because uh you're uh trying to pass messages on to the US president. You're also trying to pass messages on
[32:59]to a Congress which is up for whose members are up for reelection, all 435 of them [clears throat] this coming November. And for the domestic audience
[33:09]back home in the UK, >> at the risk of disagreeing with an esteemed political operator like Jim, I would suggest that um it's probably uh
[33:20]we can still flatter Donald Trump and maybe that's what the king is there for. Maybe our politicians can stand up to him on one side and the king can flatter on the other. But yeah, of course, huge domestic audience. Um, just to mention
[33:32]that the um is some reporting now just coming out saying that the king will acknowledge the Epstein victims in the US Congress speech. I mean, we'll have to wait and see obviously will it be
[33:43]some roundabout acknowledgement of, you know, in general terms, but yeah, re really important speech coming up, you know, in just about an hour's time. um
[33:54]historic historic occasion. >> Laura Carter again it's uh we there was a consensus it's here on the panel that
[34:04]uh the current UK prime minister would be out soon. Again, what tone does the UK take going forward uh uh when it comes to the United States? were call, you know, some are calling this the
[34:16]biggest crisis the two countries have had since since the Suez Canal in 1956 when the Americans uh pressured the UK and France to uh uh stop trying to
[34:27]overthrow uh the government of Egypt. Well, I think going forward um UK domestically is and people are fixated on what the consequence of the Iran war
[34:38]are going to be for energy prices and all these kinds of things and that is obviously directly linked to the US and Israel. >> Yeah. Every time somebody fills the tank, they're thinking of Donald Trump's
[34:49]decision to go to war. >> Yeah. And generally speaking, you know, he's not hugely popular in the UK um amongst the kind of ordinary general public. I think it's fair to say. and that, you know, there's there's whispers
[34:59]that if if if the king cozies up too much to him in in the speech, that will alienate um [clears throat] you know, domestic British people. Um he's not Yeah, he's not quite the flavor that
[35:10]we're used to in a US president. But I think going forward, you just have to you'll have to react to Trump mostly. It's it's very hard to to to look at what the UK strategy is in relation to
[35:21]the US um in a kind of much longer term view. Do you agree with Tom Sykes that the flattery is a necessary exercise if you're the king? >> I think to some extent I think the best the card that the UK's got that other
[35:32]that France hasn't got that Finland hasn't got is the royal family right it is all this kind of pageantry and all the sparkly things that he likes and the association with his British heritage Scottish heritage um and the king kind
[35:43]of uniquely can do that so um I think he's he's doing his bit you know he's he's useful some for something and it's definitely this >> Jeremy St. I I think the king's real
[35:54]card is not to flatter Donald Trump but to allow himself to be flattered by Donald Trump. >> Most of the enthusiasm will be seen to
[36:03]be going that way and the king should uh suck it up, just drink it all up. Uh the problem at the moment is that uh across
[36:13]Europe, populist parties are distancing themselves from Donald Trump over the Iran war, but over other things as well. Uh, I think even if Nigel Farage were in
[36:24]power, now there's a Trump whisperer if ever there were one, he would not be quite as um uh in in keeping, you know,
[36:34]in touch in in lock step as it were with Donald Trump as one might suppose. So that um the king should allow himself to be flattered whilst also showing people
[36:45]back in Europe that he is no lap dog as it were. He is there uh to represent I would say not only Great Britain to some
[36:55]extent Europe and above all history common history and everything should be extremely extremely dignified at least
[37:05]on the British side. Uh I don't know what antics uh Mr. Trump will get up to. He has all sorts of ideas. Some of them good, some of them not so good. But the
[37:16]king should allow himself to be flattered with dignity. >> Uh you heard us Jim Towns and uh with
[37:24]Laura Carter uh talking about uh that the the low point, the last one being uh 1956
[37:34]uh uh and the Suez crisis. I is this worse? >> No, I you know I don't think so. I think
[37:44]the 56 Suez crisis uh that that was a major historic event not just because of what was happening there in the in the Middle East but it was a real swing in
[37:54]terms of US leadership uh shoulders above uh both France and the UK. Uh that was a time when the US began to really stride across the post uh World War II
[38:06]stage. And so that really it it was a bit of a shock uh I think both to UK and to France as well as to the American people at the time that suddenly Eisenhower came out like this and the US
[38:18]was really flexing these muscles because what's happening now I I just I guess I'll repeat myself a little bit is so much of a political spat between uh
[38:28]politicians and personalities. It's not a big muscle movement as we say. It is something that is um the froth on the
[38:36]top of what is actually a uh strong um special relationship, a people-to-people relationship between the US and the UK, the shared history, the shared values,
[38:46]all that come with that. Um if it wasn't Donald Trump up there throwing these bricks, we wouldn't be in this place right now. Um except for those who worry about the military capabilities.
[38:58]>> Yeah. You you say if it wasn't for Donald Trump, but again, let's go back to the original reason for the official reason for this state visit, which is to
[39:08]celebrate ahead of the July 4th will be the 250th anniversary of uh US independence from Britain. Uh when you
[39:18]think back to the 200th in 1976, Lauren Carter was talking about it earlier. uh uh and you know all the talk about
[39:27]shared values back then does it still resonate the same way there's people questioning whether US democracy is what
[39:36]it was >> well uh that's important uh point uh I I I think you know I think at its core I
[39:47]think at its core the US is is is has those values that we had in 1976 as well at its core. Uh I will say the demography of the United States is
[39:58]changing and the US itself is a bit of a different country than it was in in 76. But I think that core value that links with uh Great Britain is is still there.
[40:08]So I I but I understand certainly again with the this administration and with Donald Trump himself, they have been doing things that makes not just Europe
[40:18]but a lot of Americans wonder what's happened to our values just in the way it's expressed uh by the White House and the things that Donald Trump does. But when he passes from the scene and when
[40:29]the maggot event passes a bit as well, I don't think you're going to see an America that has uh that is um has ch the changed values that it looks like
[40:40]when you see ICE in the streets. I think I think uh that the core US is still largely what it looks like on a person-toperson basis and the main
[40:51]streets of America still a bit what it was like in 76 and not what it looks like today. When you see the administration policies being acted out, you hear the rhetoric, you see pictures
[41:03]of ICE in the street, you wonder what has happened to the United States. That is more an expression of this administration and and the personalities of some of the people running it than it
[41:14]is to what the average American really feels. >> Well, let's ask the Englishman in New York, Tom Sykes. This too shall pass. >> Oh, I think it'll definitely pass. And I
[41:28]think that um you know we must we must remember everything that the United States and the United Kingdom have been through have achieved together
[41:39]shoulderto-shoulder and you know Trump is a very very difficult leader. He's not like anything we've ever seen before. He doesn't come from a political background. I think that's half of the issue. So he doesn't feel constrained by
[41:50]the kind of norms. And let's just hope that this too shall pass. We'll have to leave it there for now. Tom Sykes, so many thanks for being with us from New
[42:00]York. I want to thank uh Jim Townsen in Washington, Laura Carter, Jeremy Stubs, thank you for being with us. Reminder, see that speech at uh 900 p.m. Paris
[42:11]time, 8:00 p.m. in the UK, 300 p.m. in Washington by [music] King Charles before a joint session of the US Congress. Thanks for being with us here
[42:22]in the France 24 debate. >> [music]