Court Records
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, FOURTH DISTRICT DCA NO.4D2024-0681 L.T. NO.50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, Publisher of THE PALM BEACH P ST 4,....., Appellant(s), VS. 4s. DAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of Palm Beach Coun Flo ida and SHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm Be C ty, Florida Appellee(s). RECORD ON APEAL CtAPPEAL FROM THE CIR T COURT OF THE 15T" JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALI EACH COUNTY, FL (CIRCUIT CIVIL DIVISION) NINA D. BOY boyajiannt om [Email Redacted] MICHAEL J. GRYGIEL [Email Redacted] COLLIN DOERN [Email Redacted] JESSICA NEER MCDONALD [Email Redacted] FaTRIA9i9Eg UNTY, FL 000001 ABRUZZO, CLERK 04/17/2024 03:04:47 PM EFTA02736846 STEPHEN ARTHUR MENDELSOHN [Email Redacted] [Email Redacted] [Email Redacted] DOUGLAS ARTHUR WYLER [Email Redacted] RECORDS ON APPEAL 000002 EFTA02736847 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC Pa es 04/17/24 PROGRESS DOCKET 11/14/19 CIVIL COVER SHEET -4A rigg-s0013 0014-0015 Date Instrument 11/15/19 VERIFIED MOTION: FOR ADMISSION OF MIC QI 0106-0111 11/14/19 COMPLAINT: F/B PLT 0016-0105 11/19/19 ORDER: HAFELE DTD 11/19/19: MOTION TO P 12/06/19 MOTION TO DISMISS: F/B DFT DAVE ARQNBER AS 0114-0116 12/13/19 MOTION TO DISMISS: F/B DFT SHARONRBOCK AS 0117-0120 01/16/20 ORDER SETTING HEARING: KMARZ DTD 1/16/20 O 0121-0122 01/16/20 VERIFIED MOTION: AS TO PRO HA VI, E1OF NINA 0123-0127 01/17/20 COMPLAINT: FIRST AMEN Be 0128-0221 01/17/20 NOTICE OF FILING: FIRST DED COMPLAINT F 0222-0317 01/21/20 ORDER: KMARX DTD 1/21/ NCELLING HEARIN 0318-0319 01/21/20 OBJECTION: PLAINTIFF'S OB E_CTION TO DEFENDA 01/22/20 ORDER GRANTING: DHACIELEDTD 1/22/20 MOTION 0323-0324 01/24/20 ANSWER: TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTI 0325-0337 01/24/20 ANSWER: TO FIRST 'MENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTI 0338-0351 le 02/03/20 ORDER SETTING ARING: MARTZ DTD 2/3/20: 3 0352-0353 03/12/20 NOTICE: OPPOSI ON/TO DFT DAVE ARONBEG STAT 03/12/20 NOTICE: OPPOSITION TO DFT SHARON R. BOCK CL 03/18/20 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL: PLAINTIFF'S U 0393-0395 03/20/20 ORDER CONTINUANCE: MARX DTD 03/19 0396-0397 04/21/20 ORDER ETTING: ON MOTION TO DISMISS COUNT 05/22/20 ORD ING HEARING: MARX DTD 05/22/20 0400-0403 05/27/20 NO I AME/ADDRESS CHANGE: CHANGE OF ATTY 0404-0404 06/08/20 RANTING: MARX; DFTS MOTIONS TO D 0405-0411 06/10/20 N -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: AND DIRECTIONS 0412-0412 07/01/20 MO ON: DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S MOTION F 0413-0414 08/18/20 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: DEFENDANT DAVE 0415-0423 08/18/20 AFFIDAVIT: AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID ARONBERG 0424-0425 09/18/20 MOTION: MOTION TO SET CASE MANAGEMENT CONFE 0426-0459 10/02/20 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN OPPOSITION TO THE STA 0460-0473 10/14/20 RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFF'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW 0474-0498 10/21/20 ORDER: HAFELE DTD 10/21/20: CASE MANAGEMEN 0499-0499 10/21/20 MOTION: MOTION TO SET HEARING ON DEFENDANT, 0500-0501 10/21/20 NOTICE OF DROPPING PARTY: AS TO DFT DAVE AR 0502-0503 10/29/20 MOTION: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO DIRECT THE CL 0504-0507 000003 EFTA02736848 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC 11/09/20 MOTION: DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'S AMENDED 0508-0566 11/09/20 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AFFIDAVIT OF AT 567-0586 11/19/20 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: VERIFIED AFFIDA 0587-0590 01/28/21 NOTICE: OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY OF RECOR 0591-0592 01/28/21 ORDER SETTING HEARING: HAFELE DTD 01/2 0593-0595 03/25/21 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: CHANG OF UN 0596-0596 04/22/21 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: AND INCORPORAT 0597-0631 04/22/21 APPENDIX: TO MOTION PLTS' MOTION FOR, UMMAR 0632-1341 05/24/21 MOTION: PLAINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLJIONQS LLC 1342-1345 05/25/21 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: AS 140UN EL FOR 1346-1348 05/25/21 RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFFS MOI16100'SCHEDULE 1349-1352 06/11/21 AGREED ORDER: HAFELE; ON PrgS ' MOTION TO S 07/15/21 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: AND RE ONSE IN OPPOSITI 1355-1367 07/23/21 AFFIDAVIT: OF DAVID ARONBERry., FIL 1368-1369 07/23/21 TRANSCRIPT: OF HEARING' ONfi-3-20 1370-1391 07/23/21 MEMORANDUM OF LAW. 6ZUPPORT OF DAVE ARONB 1392-1413 07/26/21 ORDER SETTING HEARIN • D RAFFLE DTD. 1414-1417 07/26/21 NOTICE OF APPEA ANCB IVIL: F/B ATTY WHETST 1418-1420 07/26/21 ORDER RESETTING: DHAFELE DTD 7/26/21 HEARI 1421-1424 07/29/21 MEMORANDUM O LAW: IN SUPPORTOF DEFENDANT D 1425-1571 08/05/21 MOTION FOR QNTINUANCE CIVIL: JOINT MOTION 1572-1574 08/09/21 ORDER: HAFE TD 8/5/21: JOINT MOTION TO 1575-1577 08/12/21 MEMOR U F LAW: AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LA 1578-1915 10/01/21 RESP S TO:: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMAR 1916-1942 10/05/21 ORD A ELE: CONFIRMING HEARING ON PLAINT 1943-1946 10/13/21 RE SPONSE: IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOYIO 1947-1957 12/20/21 FI(JA.1 DGMENT: D HAFELE DTD 12/20/2021 1958-1971 01/03/22 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: AND DESIGNATION 01/03/22 MOTION: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR 1975-1979 01/19/22 MOTION: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR 1980-1987 01/26/22 NOTICE: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR 1988-1989 01/27/22 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 1 1990-2010 02/24/22 REPLY/RESPONSE: [AMENDED] Li ORANDUM OF 2011-2029 03/30/22 MOTION TO WITH' = /B DFT ABRUZZO 03/30/22 EXHIBIT: F/B DFT ABRUZ • LERK AN 2033-2034 04/13/22 NOTICE: DEFEND • E ARONBERG'S NOTICE O 2035-2036 04/13/22 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AMENDED & SUPPL 2037-2118 000004 EFTA02736849 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC 04/14/22 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AMENDED AND SUP 05/25/22 ORDER SETTING HEARING: D. HAFELE DTD 05/25/ 06/07/22 ORD SUBSTITUTION COUNSEL: HAFELE; COLIN D 07/01/22 ORDER SETTING HEARING: HAFELE: (RESETTIN 07/22/22 MOTION: AGREED MOTION OF PLAINTIFF CA 2119-2122 2123-2126 2127-2129 2130-2132 2133-2152 SUBMITWRI 09/28/22 AGREED ORDER: DELGADO: ON JOINT MOTION FOR 2159-2159 10/04/22 EXHIBIT LIST 2160-2161 10/04/22 TRANSCRIPT: HEARING PROCEEDINGS D SEPTE 2162-2440 10/06/22 NOTICE: CLOSING ARGUMENT OF t P DANT, DAVE 2441-2469 10/06/22 NOTICE: WRITTEN CLOSING AR IJM T OF CA FLOR 2470-2574 02/01/23 ORDER DENYING: L DELGAD Q . 1/31/23 2575-2576 02/01/23 MOTION: TO ALTER OR AME D ORDER DENYING THE 2577-2578 02/16/23 RESPONSE TO:: IN OPPO TO STATE ATTY D 2579-2585 03/01/23 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVI DER RENDERED ON 1 2586-2589 03/06/23 ORDER: DELGADO DTO 3 : MOTION TO ALTER 2590-2591 03/10/23 NOTICE OF APPEALCIVIL! ORDER RENDERED ON 3 2592-2595 05/11/23 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: F/B ATTY JACK S 2596-2597 06/09/23 ORDER: DELGADO; DIRECTING CLERK TO COURT TO 2598-2600 06/29/23 ORDER: DELG$OO DTD 6/29/23: DIRECTING TRA 2601-2604 02/23/24 MOTION: THE ASSOCIATED PRESS' MOTION FOR LI 2605-2608 02/28/24 AGREED DER: L DELGADO DTD. 2/28/24 GRANT 2609-2609 02/29/24 ORDE ELGADO DTD 2/29/2024 ON GRAND JU 2610-2614 03/01/24 MOTIO FiE MCCLATCHY COMPANY, LLC'S MOTION 2615-2617 03/04/24 NOTI HE MCCLATCHY COMPANY, LLC'S NOTICE 2618-2619 03/05/24 AGREE ORDER: DELGADO DTD 3/5/24: MOTION 2620-2620 03/14/24 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 2 2621-2629 04/17/24 CERTIFICATE 4262-4262 000005 EFTA02736850 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC Party Description Pages JOINT J18 AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID ARONBERG 2630-2631 JOINT J16 TO D. WYLER FROM S MENDELS itiogiiii JOINT J24 SCHOLZ & WYLER INVOICE 2635-2641 JOINT J20 ANDUM OF LAW OF PLAINTIFF retDI 2642-2655 JOINT J21 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S RES E TO 2656-2680 JOINT J13 HEARING TRANSCRIPT 2681-2685 JOINT J19 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'§ -00N FOR SU 2686-2694 JOINT J17 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERqSzsMOtION FOR AT 2695-2696 JOINT J10 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBE GAVSTATE ATTOR 2697-2709 JOINT J23 PLAINTIFF CA HOLDINGS .S NOTICE OF 2710-2711 JOINT J15 ORDER GRANTING DEF5t1 NtS MOTION TO DIS JOINT J11 DEFENDANT ARONBE 1- TER POST 2719-2720 JOINT J12 SAO15 PRESS RELEA 2721-2721 JOINT J22 LETTER TO D. WYIER FROM S MENDELSOHN 2722-2723 JOINT J14 EMAIL TO S. MENDELSOHN FROM D WYLER 2724-2728 JOINT J05 LETTER TO J. QWARD FROM D. WYLER 2729-2729 JOINT J04 SUMMONS 0.,QMPLAINT 2730-2821 JOINT J08 ORDER DE THE STATE'S MOTION FOR AN 2822-2828 JOINT J06 MOTION TO D MISS 2829-2831 JOINT J03 LETTER USGRAVE FROM N. CRUZ JOINT J02 LEVER J. PACENTI FROM N. CRUZ 2835-2835 JOINT J07 M N FOR AN ORDER UNSEALING GRAND JUR 2836-2841 JOINT J01 TO D. ARONBERG FROM S. MENDELSOH 2842-2844 JOINT J T AMENDED COMPLAINT (PART II) 2845-2938 JOINT ST AMENDED COMPLAINT (PART I) 2939-2964 JOINT DGMENT 2965-2978 JOINT J SCHOLZ & WYLER INVOICE 2979-2987 JOINT J26 IT OF ATTORNEY'S FEES 2988-3007 JOINT J31 AMENDED RESPONSE AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW 3008-3026 JOINT J28 MOTION OF PLALINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLDING 3027-3061 JOINT J25 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'S AMENDED MOTIO 3062-3120 JOINT J37 LETTER FROM M GRYGIEL TO D. ARONBERG 3121-3123 JOINT J34 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S NOTICE OF DR 3124-3125 JOINT J36 JAMES V WILLE, 480 SO.2D. 253 (1985) 3126-3128 JOINT J33 AMENDED & SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF AT 3129-3210 JOINT J35 AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF 3211-3214 000006 EFTA02736851 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC JOINT J29 AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPOR 3215-3374 JOINT J29 AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPO 3375-3552 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA H- 3553-3725 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO 3726-3900 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO 3901-4086 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO 4087-4261 000007 EFTA02736852 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE # Effective Date Count Description 1 11/14/2019 CIVIL COVER SHEET 2 11/14/2019 SUMMONS ISSUED 3 11/14/2019 SUMMONS ISSUED 4 11/14/2019 COMPLAINT A' 5 11/15/2019 DIVISION ASSIGNMENT 6 11/15/2019 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT BER> 7 11/15/2019 VERIFIED MOTION 8 11/15/2019 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECC MBER> 9 11/19/2019 ORDER 10 11/25/2019 SERVICE RETURNS BERED) 11 11/25/2019 SERVICE RETUR MBERED) 12 12/6/2019 MOTION TO DI 13 12/13/2019 MOTION TO Or 14 1/16/2020 ORDER SFtTIFIG HEARING 15 1/16/2020 VERIFIED MOTION 16 1/17/2020 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 17 1/17/2020 C PLAINT 18 1/17/2020 N E OF FILING 19 1/21/2020 ORP R 21 1/21/2020 OBJECTION 20 1/22/2020 ORDER GRANTING 22 1/24/20 ANSWER 23 1/24 0 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 24 1/ 0 ANSWER 25 0 ORDER SETTING HEARING 26 3 /2020 NOTICE 27 3/12/2020 NOTICE 28 3/18/2020 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL 29 3/20/2020 ORDER OF CONTINUANCE 30 4/21/2020 ORDER RESETTING 31 5/22/2020 ORDER SETTING HEARING 32 5/27/2020 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE 33 6/8/2020 ORDER GRANTING 34 6/10/2020 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE 35 7/1/2020 MOTION 000008 EFTA02736853 Case Description: CA Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 'Effective Count Description Date 36 7/10/2020 REQUEST TO PRODUCE 37 7/24/2020 REQUEST TO PRODUCE 38 8/18/2020 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 39 8/18/2020 AFFIDAVIT 40 9/2/2020 RESPONSE TO REQ TO PRODUC 41 9/18/2020 MOTION 42 9/22/2020 1 NOTICE OF HEARING 43 10/2/2020 I MEMORANDUM OF LAW 44 10/2/2020 RESPONSE TO: 45 10/14/2020 RESPONSE TO: 46 10/21/2020 ORDER 47 10/21/2020 MOTION 48 10/21/2020 NOTICE OF G PARTY 49 10/29/2020 MOTION 50 11/9/2020 MOTIOI,,e s> 51 11/9/2020 AFFI IT F ATTORNEY FEES 52 11/19/2020 AFFQ OF ATTORNEY FEES 53 12/3/2020 NO OF NON JURY TRIAL 54 12/10/2020 NO CE OF NON JURY TRIAL 55 1/28/2021 NOTICE 56 1/28/2021 ORDER SETTING HEARING 57 3/25/20 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE 58 4/2 1 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 59 4/ 0 APPENDIX 60 1 MOTION 61 I • /2021 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL 62 5/25/2021 RESPONSE TO: 63 6/11/2021 AGREED ORDER 641 7/15/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 66 7/23/2021 AFFIDAVIT 67 7/23/2021 TRANSCRIPT 68 7/23/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 65 7/26/2021 ORDER SETTING HEARING 69 7/26/2021 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL 70 7/26/2021 ORDER RESETTING 000009 EFTA02736854 Case Description: CA Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE Count Description _____ Effective Date 71 7/29/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 72 8/5/2021 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL 73 8/9/2021 ORDER 74 8/12/2021 I MEMORANDUM OF LAW 75 10/1/2021 RESPONSE TO: 76 10/5/2021 ORDER 77 10/13/2021 REPLY/RESPONSE 78 12/20/2021 FINAL JUDGMENT 79 12/20/2021 DISPOSED AFTER OTHER 80 1/3/2022 NOTICE OF APPEARV CIVIL 81 1/3/2022 MOTION 4CI' 82 1/19/2022 MOTION 89 1/26/2022 NOTICE 83 1/27/2022 NOTICE O AL CIVIL 84 1/27/2022 PAID <AMOU > ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 85 1/27/2022, AUTOMATI RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 86 1/27/2022 ACKNOOrEDGMENT OF NEW CASE 87 1/27/2022 TRUE COPY 88 1/28/2022 E TR COPY 90 2/24/2022 PLY/RESPONSE 91 3/22/2022 ,INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL 92 3/22/20 INVOICE 93 3/23 2 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 94 3/ 0 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 95 2 MOTION TO WITHDRAW 96 3 /2022 EXHIBIT 99 4/13/2022 NOTICE 100 4/13/2022 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES 97 4/14/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 98 4/14/2022 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES 101 4/20/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 102 4/28/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 103 5/25/2022 ORDER SETTING HEARING 10,11._ 5/31/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 105 6/2/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 000010 EFTA02736855 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE Count # 106 107 Effective Date Description 6/7/2022 ORD SUBSTITUTION COUNSEL 7/1/2022 ORDER SETTING HEARING 1081 109 1101 7/22/2022 MOTION 9/1/2022 9/8/2022 EVIDENCE/EXHIBIT LIST FILED ____ CLERK'S NOTE 111 9/26/2022 MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF 112 9/28/2022 AGREED ORDER 113 10/4/2022 EXHIBIT LIST 114 10/4/2022 TRANSCRIPT 115 10/6/2022 NOTICE 116 10/6/2022 NOTICE 117 2/1/2023 ORDER DENYI 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 2/1/2023 MOTION 2/16/2023 3/1/2023 i RESPON NOTICE A EAL CIVIL PAID MO NT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 3/1/2023, 3/1/2023 A • IC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 3/3/2023 3/6/2023 A LEDGMENT OF NEW CASE Till COPY 3/6/2023 3/10/2023, ORDER NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL 127 3/10/20 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 128 3/20 • 3 TRUE COPY 129 3/ EXHIBIT CHECK OUT RECEIPT 130 3 JOINT EVIDENCE 131 132 133 3 /2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 1341 135 136 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 137 3/27/2023 - JOINT EVIDENCE 138 139 140 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE 000011 EFTA02736856 Case Description: CA Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE Count Description # Effective Date 141 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 142 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 143 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 144 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 145 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 146 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 147 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 148 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 149 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 150 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 151 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 152 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDEN 153 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDEt 154 3/27/2023 JOINT EV 155 3/27/2023 JOINT E 156 3/27/2023 JOI VID NCE 157 3/27/2023 J ENCE 158 3/27/2023 T VIDENCE 159 3/27/2023 JO EVIDENCE 160 3/27/2023 J INT EVIDENCE 161 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 162 3/27/20 ' JOINT EVIDENCE 163 3/27 • 3 JOINT EVIDENCE 164 3/ 0 JOINT EVIDENCE 165 13 JOINT EVIDENCE 166 3 /2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 167 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 168 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 169 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 170 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 171 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 172 4/5/2023 INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL 173. 4/5/2023 INVOICE 174 4/14/2023 <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> __PAID 175 4/17/2023 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 000012 EFTA02736857 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE Effective Date Count Description 176 177 4/20/2023 5/2/2023 178 5/11/2023 179 5/26/2023 188 5/26/2023 180 6/9/2023 181 6/29/2023 182 2/23/2024 183 2/28/2024 184 2/29/2024 185 3/1/2024 186 3/4/2024 187 3/5/2024 189 3/14/2024 190 3/14/2024 191 3/14/2024 192 3/15/2024 193 3/15/2024 194 3/15/2024 195 4/3/2024 196 4/4/2024 EXHIBIT CHECK IN RECEIPT TRUE COPY NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL MANDATE REVERSED/REMANDED ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ORDER ORDER MOTION AGREED ORDER ORDER AGREED ORDER MOTION NOTICE O 13,EAL CIVIL PAID <AMOU > ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> NOTICE OPINION AUTO TIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING ACKNlaWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE COPY TI ON MANDATE -AFFIRMED 000013 EFTA02736858 ABRUZZO LA.r.tru• ur r. LIKUL IT COURT & COMPTROLLER County CIMI Division PO Box 3406 West Palm Beach. FL 33402 PALM BEACH COUNTY F. ([Phone Redacted] F ([Phone Redacted] CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK 4th DCA NO.: 4D2024-0681 ABRUZZO, Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comp r, in and for Palm Beach County, State of Florida, do hereby certi at e foregoing pages of: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THECQEACH POST vs DAVE ARONBEg i4c) CASE NO: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX contains true and correct transcripts pies of all such papers and proceedings in said cause as app k fr the records and files of my office that have been directed t inbtuded in said RECORD by the directions furnished to me, vytth Clactions required by law, rule or administrative order. IN WITNESS WH F, I have hereunto my hand affixed the seal of the court, this 1To lf,April, 2024 By: ABRUZZO CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTROLLER Palm Beach County, FL. Brent Robbins Deputy Clerk Main Courthouse North County Courthouse Midwestern Service Center West County Courthouse South County Courthouse 205 N Dixie Hwy 3188 PGA Blvd. 200 Civic Center Way. Suite 500 2950 State Road 15. Room 5-100 200 W Atlantic Ave West Palm Beach. FL Palm Beach Gardens. FL MParrnBildi062 Belle Glade. FL Delray Beach. FL EFTA02736859