EFTA02735462
Court Records
Document Pages (20) #
Extracted Text #
This text was extracted automatically from the scanned pages and may contain errors. Check any quotation against the original scan above or the source document.
Filing # 116366269 E-Filed 11/09/2020 02:14:01 PM • I IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, Publisher of the PALM BEACH POST, Plaintiff, V. DAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida; SHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm Beach County, Florida. Defendants. AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORN 'c „) STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF NASSAU being first duly sworn, deposes and sa I. Affiant is a OBS, SCHOLZ & WYLER, LLC, counsel for - Defendant, DAVE ARON to Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida, ("Aronberg"), as well as general counsel to t orida Prosecuting Attorneys Association, ("FPAA"), and makes this Affidavit o his o rsonal knowledge.. 2. iant is licensed to practice law in the State of Florida, is an active member of the FAIo in good standing and has engagedin the practice of law in the State of Florida since CASE 19-CA- 4681 CO 'S eSf \"ScBEFORE ME, the undersigned a • red Douglas A. Wyler, Esq., who, after cu 3. As detailed herein, the services rendered by Afflant and his firm pertain to Affiant's demand letter and motion for attorneys' fees sent to Plaintiff's counsel pursuant to § 57.105, ' 'FltiritIFStiftlItEST6Witlftn, 2020,1iTtlefeWdirfg against COift nif Party JOINT IDS. J26 EV# 0ATEADWTTED: Joint Exhibit Camerae. 2019-CA414.1 MILABRUZZO CLERK WI COURT J26 CA/ArOPIRIEIB9093091 BEACH COUNTY, 0, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735462 . • and Plaintiffs October 21, 2020 Notice of Dropping State Attorney, Dave Aronberg from the • aboye7captioned lawsuit. See,. Exhibits "A" and qB" attacfreif hereto.. • • • . 4. The total time Affiantil law.firm has expended serVices rendered to date is 74.8 . • hours, however, from the date of Defendant iiicinberg's 57.105 demand; Affiatit's law flint expended a total of 421 boors. Of the 42.2 hours. since Defendant Aronbe 57.195 , . • " • deritendWas served, the Aft-lent . Of the 42.2 hours expended since Defendant Aronberg' and was.:• . . served, the total time 'Affiant has expended services rendered to date ' rs at the rate of • $425.00 per hour. LikeWite,the total time Affianestayi pa has expended services rendered to date is 6.8 hours at the rate of $475. _ • . .‘ AcCordingly, since Defendant Aron demand was served, Defendant Aronberg's counsel, JACOBS, SCHOLZ & W L , has rendered services in the amount of $18,275.00, in conjunction with the d instant action pursuant to § 57.105, Florida Statutes. See, Exhibit "C" attache 7. Affiant expec additional 4.0 hours at $425.00 an hour in preparing for and attending the hearing o tto eys' fees. Thus, the total amount of hourly attorneys' fees the t6State Attorney is see ' .2 hours for a total of $19,975.00. Additionally, the State Attorney seeks a rritilf ier of 2. , which when applied makes the grand total attorneys' fees sought herein $39,9 DaOday of November, 2020. FURTHER AFFIANISAYETH NOT. ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM CA/AroPIEFIVP901101 BEACH COUNTY, FL, EFTA02735463 STATE OF FLORIDA . • . COUNTY (*.NASSAU . • • • . • • • • • •• • • : The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 9th day of November, 2020, by Do . Wyler, Esquire, who is personilly known to rneind who did take an oath. • • • Sign wary Public — State of Florida Name typed, printed or stamped CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBrCERTIFY that on this 9th day of Novem a copy of the foregoing has been electronically filed with the Florida E-File Portal on all patties of record herein. O SCHOLZ & WYLER, LLC ugh: A. Wyler Arthur I. Esq. Ha. Bar No.: 10249 • Richard J. Scholz, Esq. Fla. Bar No.: 0021261 Douglas A. Wykr, Esq. Fla. Bar No.: 119979 961687 GateWay Blvd., Suite 201-I Fernandina Beach, Florida 32034 (904)261-3693 (904) 261-7879 Fax Primary: jacobsscholzlaw@comcast.net Attorneys for Defendant. Dave Aronberg • . . CA/Ar0FINFID0MNI BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735464 E IBI'"'' EFTA02735465 . . .. . ' • ,.. , • . Friday, September 18,20W at 11:0924 Eastern Daylight Time sawed: SERVICE OF CURT DOCUMENT CASE NO; 1019-CA-014881; CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC V. DAVE AR0N118RG ET AL. DIM: Monday, June 8, 2020 at3:88:58 PM Eastern Daylight Time Freely To: 'mendelsohns.gtlaw.cOme, smithleigtlaw.com, fiserviceegtlaw.corp, BoyalianNtbatlaw.Com, riveraal@gtia,coin, GRYGIELMCagtlaw.com Attachments: 2020-06;08 Aronberg 57.105 DeMand and Motion for Attorney? Fees.pdf • • Court: Case No: Plaintiff: Defendant: Title of Documents Served: ...• Sender's Name and Telephone Number: Sincerely, Circuit Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, in and for Pairn. Florida • " Case:No. 2020-CA-014681 CA Florida Holdings, LLC Dave Aronbetg • Fla. Stat.* 57.10S Demand Letter •; Defendant, Dave Aronberg's Motion Douilas Wyler (904) 261.3693 Doug Wyler, Esq. Scholcaleyler, LLC t 961687 Gateway Blvd., STE 201-I Fernandina Beach, FL 32034 904-261-3693 904-261-7879 (fax) orneys' Fees Please be advised that this e-ma nd a y files transmitted with It are confidential attorney-client communication or may otherwise rivileged or confidential and are intended solely for the Individual or entity to whom they are sed. If you are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy or retransmit this Communica t destroy it immediately. Any unauthorizeildissemination, distribution or copying of this co tt unitab is strictly prohibited. Pagel of 1 CA/AroPtifElgiMal BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735466 junel, 2020 SCHOLZ & WYLER, I...L A UNIT LIAINUTY COMPANY OF PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS ATTORNEYS AT LAW GATEWAY TO AMELIA ' 0016S7 GATEWAY BLVD.. SUITE 501.1 PN*OIANDENA Bera, notes 32034 TELEPHONE (904) es 1 aego rki NO. (po.) 561.7670 • . . VIA ELECTRONIC & U.S. MAIkr Stephen:A. Mendelsohn, Esq. • dieenburg Traurig, P.A. . • 5100 Town Center Circle, Suite 400 Boca Raton, FL 33486 RE: CA Florida Holdings, LI.,C v. Dave Aron • Palm Beach County, Case No.: 2019-CA Dear Mr. Mendelsohn: SONOLZ. PA RDEPIA90.1. 964012 ". • DOUBCAS AAfgair.m. DOLPOCAS A. "rant . .• . As you are aware our firm representi the interes tOnberg, as State Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida: in the above referenced se of this letter is to demand the voluntary dismissal of your First Amended Complai plaint"), dated January 17, 2020. This demand . is made pursuant to'section 57.105, Flori S tes. • • As you know, Section 57. (1) Upon the court' reasonable an prevailing part on any c aim or the court have kno or motion of any party, the court shall award a including prejudgment interest, to be paid to the I amounts by the losing party Andthe losing patty's attorney ense it any time during:a civil proceeding or action in which t the losing party or the losing party's attorney knew or should t a claim or defense when initially presented to the court or at any befo rial: . ' Was not supported by the material facts necessary to establish the claim or defense; or . • b. Would not be supported by the application of then-existing law to thole material facts. Ti , Judge Marx granted, with prejudice. Defendant Aronberes Motion to Dismiss Count U of the 'Pia' tiff's Complaint. Purauant to the Court's ruling, the Plaintiff's only remaining cause of action consists of Count-I, for Declaratory Relief. Accordingly, we 6e.lieve that•theCoinplaint filed herein and its sole remaining Count for Declaratory Relief is not supported by the material facts necessary to establish the claims asserted,-and that your claims are not supported by the application of current law tosaid m'aterial facts ` *, • • CA/Aa0003714 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735467 First and foremost, the Complaint is not supported by the material facts necessary to establish the claims asserted because neither Defendant Aronberg, nor The Office of the State Attorney for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit is in custody or control of the 2006 grand jury materials sought therein. Simply put, the declaratory relief sought by the Plaintiff, seeks records 'from my client that arc impossible for him or his office to produce. Accordingly, Defendant Aronberg is not a proper party to this action because no matter what, he and his office do not have possession, custody, or control of the requested materials. In addition to the foregoing material facts that negate the claims asserted in the Complaint, your claims arc also not supported by the application of current law. Specifically, your action for declaratory relief fails based on the clear, unambiguous statutory language found in Section 905.27(2k/1°rib Statutes, which states: When such disclosure is ordered by a court pursuant to subsection (1), for us in a civil case, it may be disclosed to all parties to the case and to their attorneys and by the latter to their legal associates and employees. However the grand fi r tesliniarry afforded such persons by the court can only be used in the defense or prthecutign of the civil or criminal case andfor no other purpose whatsoever. Moreover, even if the Plaintiff were to prevail in the declar9etity a Mr. Aronberg would be unable to comply with any court order granting disclosure of t elt documents because neither Mr. Aronberg nor The Office of the State Attorney for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit have possession, custody, or control of the 2006 Epstein grand jury records. Based on the foregoing, if the Complaint is not dismissed within 21 days of the service of this letter, the enclosed Motion for Attorney's Fees will be filed and we will seek as sanctions, from your client and your firm, recovery of the legal ex ses inferred in defending this frivolous action. Please govern yourself accordingl, Douglas A. Wyler, Esq. For the Firm End.: Defendant's ion for Attorneys' Fees CAthrOP1IIIMPPCWIC1 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735468 IN THE CIRCUIT ppuET OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT f• . IN AND FOR PAIII IREACH COUNTY, FLORIDA • , • CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, Publisher of the palm BEACH POST, • • . . . Plaint4 • DAVE AEoM3Eag. as State Attorney of OchO Batch Cowl% Florida; SHARON R. BOCIC,is Clerk and Comptroller of Palm Beach'County, Florida. - ' Defendants, DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S M ATTORNEYS'FEES Defendant, DAVE ARONBERG, as Sta tSor f Palm Beach County, Florida, by and through the undersigned attorneys, moves ursuant to Florida Statutes, Section 57.105, to award him reasonable attorneys' ( for S defense of Plaintiffs First Amended Complaint, p . • (the "Complaint"), and as.gro , would show that on June 1;2020, Plaintiff was served a copy of this Motion, to the, a letter from the undersigned attorney, in accordance with subsection (4) of the above , demanding disrnissal of the Complaint, at least 71 days prior to the filing of this to . In said letter, Defendant's attorney advised Plaintiff of the facts which establish t a Complaint is without support of the facts or the law. ORE, Defendant, DAVE ARONBERO, as State Attorney' of Palm Beach Florida, respectfully requests the Cowl enter an Order requiring Plaintiff and Plaintiff's atto cys to pay said Defendant's attorneys' fees incurred herein after service of this Motion. CA/AMPtICEIDPKIE61 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735469 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this day , 2020;the foregoing was elecirotheally filed via the Florida Portal for electronic service on the parties i;frecord herein. JACOBS SCHOLZ & WYjig, tic ' 4.rippyglps A Wper. Arthur:I.. Jacoha, Esquire Fla. Bar No.: 108249 Richard). Seholz, Esquire Fla..0ar NO.: 0021261 Douglas A. Wyl Tie. Bar No.: 961687 Gatewl ., Suite 2014 Ferhapd' h, Florida 32034 • (904) ( to aw@comcast.net ttbeys for Defendant Gs' CA/AroPiLEINDPFMNI BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735470 EXHIBIT "B" CA/Ar0P1111EDPONNI BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735471 Filing # 115383434 E-Filed 10/21/2020 04:13:35 PM • • ;CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, 1SC, Publisher of THE PALM BEAcapasz • •• • Plaintift • • v. . . . . DAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of ' Palm Beach County, Florida; SHARON It BOCIC, Cleric and Comptroller of Palm Beach County,' Florida, • ; .13efendtints. • " PLAINTIFF CA HOLDINGsnC' • NOTICEDF DROPPING STATE ATTO$NFj y. DAVE ARONBERG • • • ' ' • • • . IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE :2 FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT [NAND . FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO.: 50:201970414681 -7000;-MB DIVI$ION: AG Plaintiff, CA HOLDINGS, LLC, Pursuant to Fla. it has dropped State Attorney, Dive Aronber m above case. ), hereby notifies the ponies that espectfully submitted, . GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. Attorneys for CA Florida Holdings: LLC. Publisher of The Palm Beach Pcit . . Stephen A.•Mencielsohn..Esq. 401 East Las Olas Boulevard Suite 2000 Boca Raton, Florida 33488 Telephone: (561) 95.54629 Facsimile: (501)338-7099 By: is/ Stephen A. Mendelsohn STEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN Florida Bar No. 849424. mendelsolumettilaw:eont smithliatttlavv.eoin rLServitteetlaw.euro ; CA/AroFIGNEDP9M4 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735472 A • By: Al MIdIvael I Greek, . MICHAEL J GRYGIEL • (Adrnitted Proffeic Yice) 54 State St., 6th l; lour • • Albany', New yolk 12207 Telephone: (518) 689-1400 Facsimile: (518) 689-1499 prvgielniQsnlaw.com By Mao D. Boksiian NINA a BOYA.114N; •• (Admitted Pro lac rice) 1840 Century Parka's; Suite • Los Angeles California 9OO.12 'Telephone:- (310) 586-77(1' Facsimile: (310) S4677801/46 ) nta 1.. • • • • RTIFICATE O I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 21° foregoing has been filed with the Clerk of will send a notice oielectrOnic iervi 533,7341vI all *Th , 2020, a true and correct copy of the. the State of Florida e-filing system, which Its of record herein /s/ Stephen A. Mendelsohn STEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN 2 . . • "• • .. " • CAIAS0003a01 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735473 EXHIBIT "Cr CAMVPIOUBBNWIB BEACH COUNTY, FL. ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735474 Gateway Blvd.:Suite 2011 Fetnaridina Beach, FL 32034 United States 904-$1,3B93 Dave Arenberg Jacobs "ehdlz wyiei,lit , Balance • 4.4,41 .0.(10 Ittikokie8 • 1, Inifeloabthe t intyMeM Term Due Date Aronberg (SACI5) adv. CA. Florida Holdingt, LLC Time Endies .• • Sec . EE Activity Description ' i Rate Hooq Line Total .11/26/2019 OW Review Initial review of summons. \H ' S $425.06 14 3637.50 II/26/201g DW Review Reviewed motion for pro hac vice and Judge Hereto' order granting 5425.00 0.2 145.00 11/26/2019 DW Teleconference Teleconference W1 Client, to: response to lawsuit $425.00 . 0.5 1212.50 11/26/2019 DW Draft Dratted engagement letter and sent to client' . $425.00 0.3 . . 5127.50 11/26/2019 DW Review . Reviewed 15th circuit local rules $43.00' 1.0 • $425.00 11/26/2019 AU . Review -Weal review of complaint $05.00 1.0 3075.00 t 1/26/2019 AU Meeting ( httleetit0 w/ DAW to (sass lawsuit and Strategy $475.00 • 0.5 • - t5337 50 . . 11/26/2013 . DW Meeting ..__... Meeting w/ AIJ to discuss lawsuit and strategy - .skieoe oz. , 531250 11/292619 AU Teleconfereq 4881 Teieconference w/ Client. re: response to lawsuit 5475.00 . . , 12/024019 ' • OW , • Research & \ •-• ,. . Preparation Research and prep /Or Motion to (amiss $425.00 • . 2.0 meow .12/032019 . D ' ft ' 1st Draft motion to dismiss . S125I00 1.0 $425.00 12/02/2019 eleconference Teleconlerence WI Client, re: draft motion to dismiss 5425.00 0.5 $212.50 12/02/2019 Ay Review Reviewed 1st Draft MTDismiss • 5475.00 0.3 5143.50 i2/02/2019 . AIJ Teleconference Teleconference w/ dient. re: draft motion to . dismiss (475.00 0.5 .. 3237.50 121.0*015 : AU Meeting Meeting w/ DAW, re: motion to dismiss 1475.00 . . . . • . 03 395.00 10.040 11_,. OW Mewing.._._.... MMOPliV.4 AY, rt NI1Pierqts. ' sts.S90, 0.2 moo 12/06/20. 19 OW Draft . .. . . . cotripietco final draft of /notion to dismiss: filed with cotin • $425.06. . .61 worse . . . iweenomo DW. Teiwtontennote: . Spoke w/ client, M: final dr13O1T011O11 to dismiss 543300 - . • 0.5 -• 521350 tier 6, 020 . • CA/Arointiarg)000,38a BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735475 " • r 12/06/2019 t DW Teledonferende .! Spoke with Clerh•eatiorneW; re: response .. .• ' '.' • ..'.. 542506 0.5 $21270 12/06/2019 : AU . Review • Reviewed Mal drafilATDionifiss• • 8475.60 0.2 59s.00 ,... 12/06/2019 AU , • Review Reviewedclerks MTDismiss . - . . ... . , • • $475.00. 0.2 59500 12/13/2019, OW "'.Reviews . Reifewed Clerk's Motion to Dismiss . . . $425.0O 0.5 •- sOi26.o....• .. . , . . 01/16t2020 ••• . OW Review Reviewed Order Setting Hearing on Defendants' • *1 -Pis/fiss , t .$485.00. 342.50 . 01/162020, OW'. Review ReVilwed mobon for pro Mc vice . .. 0.1 0 ..59 0102020 . • : - Reviewed KC AmeiWiso.coioiovro • . . . .. v. ••:$425.00 .1.0 ' . 126.60 .. . . oini.so2o . .DW Teied0iitererict .Spoke with dent, re: Amended Complaint *. _ . •5 .. $212.50 bl/Ii/2020 OW Review Reviewed P1$ notice of .fifirig . .$425.60 . . 11 .01120/2025 ' AU . . Reviewed Ftstfiti. Comp . 5175. D $14.2.50 01121/2080 OW ' Review . Reviewed Judge Man's Order Cancelling MTDismiss Hewing • • - • • 0.1 Sa2 50 01121/2925 • 9* Review Reviewed Pt's Objection to Defendants' MTOisrniss ( Aril • 0.2- $85.00 01121028 OW Teleconference Spoke with client. re: Amended complaint . .o_czise .os 9212* 01/2112020 ' ' AU Meeting Meeting w/ DAW, re: response to Am. Comp': $475.00 • to• . . . $9500 . •. . 0I1 12020 ow ' Meeting Meeting wl MA re: rations. to Am. 9empl. $425.00 0.2. $85.00 01./22/2020 OW Review Reviewed Order granting pro Mc vice antiStio. ' $425.00 0.1., $42.50 • - 01/22f2020 OW R 0 a ora it Researched and drafted res nse 'Amended Complaint '1 $425.00 • 1.0 5425.00 01/23/2020 DW Teleconference Spa. Wal Clerk's rip. to amended comp!: . 54400 0.2 . $85.00 01/24/2020 OW Various Completed Answer Ns Amended filedwith d; sent copy to Client .nwr 9425.00 14 • $425'00Complaint; 0124/2620 ow Draft Drafted and filed Notice of Unavailability $425.00 0.4 $170.00. 01/24/2020 ' AU Review Reviewed final Answer/MTDismiss $475.00 0.2 $95.00 01/27/202'0 OW . Review RevieleciCUM's AnswerilATDIsmiss $425.00 0.9 $127.50 02/03/2020 - OW Review Reviewed Order setting hewing on Deis' MTDismiss $425.00 0.1 $42.50 02/03/2020 OW ronference heSpoankenowirocIrmieantle. hre2: 4order setting MTDismiss 2020 $425.00 0.5 $212.50 03/13/2020 evi)fit Reviewed Prs Opposition to Aronberg MTDismiss & Clerk's MTDismiss $425.00 1.5 $637.50 03/13/2020 45 eview ' Reviewed Pfs Opposition to konbeig MTDismiss 8 Cleric's MTDismiss sais.00 0.7 $332.50 03/18/2020 T . • Reviewed email from PCs counsel, re motion tcli. continue hearing $425.00 0.1 542.50' 03118/2020 OW Review • Reviewed RI's unopposed motion for continuance . $425.00 , 0.1 $42.50 03/18/2020..- OW . Small Emafs w/ Cleric's counsel, re: Pl's request to • continue vitiating 0.2 .• $85.00 03/.19/200 , OW E-mail Reviewed email from Pl. re: agreed acler i 5425.00 0.1 $42.50' 03/20/2020' OW Review Reviewed Coun's agreed order continuing hearing $425 .00 OA 542.50 CA/AmilliffIPOONIKI BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735476 04/21/2020 DW . , . Review '.— - .'7 Reviewed order reschedukng healing on Deis' FArbi s th iu' • . • • • • • ' . I • $42500 a 1 $42,50, 04121/2020 6v4 , sa avvesoto Spoliate ver dient, re: order reecho:luting IfT0iSnisa bowing lot June p. 2020. , • $425.00 • • -0.9,. • • . • sizi: .50 04//1/2030 AU Review Reviewed ogle iesciiiidOictialtasreisi hearing —147i.00 : O.1 . $4750 ......1—....,. WrCreglial • • . • DW Review Reviiied settirg &orb heildixt, tic '' . ' MTDISmiss ".• - ... • $425.00 • .. . . 01 • • feelg.519 . OsizzEzozo OW . ., . . ,. Teleconference .. Sidaceeil:ctient, re: hearing Ma be via Zoom: ... ..• • $425.00 .. • 492 , .... 585.00. .ordzmoio • SOW Review : Fia`Aerec!Clerg flung' change of alb; of record :* •- $425.00 :1 $4250 65272020 . DW Teleconference.' Spoke with Clerk's new counsel, NICOleiFfniticrilet . 435.00 .4,: - . $85.00 05/98/9020 DW Email Reviewed Pis email. re: come tend authonibleTh for iATDismiss hewing; responded • , . ' . ... .. oo ., • ., .. o: . . • • $42.50 05/29/2920 -. . 0W : Preparation . • . Began oral argument prep for 6P9Mthistryiss . • • • • . healing . ill • . • : • ics.o0 • 08/01/2020 •- DW . Erna; • . . :Rt Aersisp email from Judge &Wit* end 0.1 . . . • 943:59 0902/2020 DW Various ' ;Reivietered Pts 500. page binder, re: M • Prepped for hearing $42900 . 3.0 $1.975.00 . . OW E-mail Dallied and sent email to dient, re: p tomorrow 0.1 • $42S0 96/03/2020 OW Attend Hearing , Piety" for and attended TIgisrre . ng via zoom . $425.00 1.5 $8$83750• 06/03/2020 ' OW Teleoanferenei • Spokes/ Client. re:deb $425.00. os • • . $zliso 06/03/2020 OW Email Row* Courtesy copies of Answer not •MTOismiss to Judge Matte 0:1' $42.50 06/03/2020 • OW E-mail Reviewedresponse from Client and replied •- $425.00 oti- w.so 06/09/2020 AU • Attend Hearing .Attended MTI)iseniss hearing via Zoom $475.00. 1.0 $47500 ..: 06/03/2029 AU Review Reviewed order granting MTIDesmess WI poem** $475.00 0.3 • • ;His° 08/06/2020 DW Review • Ili llit Reviewed Court's Order Granting Defendants MTOismiss Count II w/ Prejudice . $42590 0.5 $2.12.50 . ...... 08/08/2020 V.. Sh9red order wr Client and SPOke w/. re: result and Il an going forward. re:57.105 .00 0.5 821290 06/08/3020 . • • • ., Researched § 57.105 Fla. Sta L: drafted 57.105 demand letter and proposed motion for attorneys' • lees/sanctions: Served Ks counsel WO demand letter and proposed motion. . . .. . $425.00 2.0 mom Meeting Meeting w/ DAW, re: Order 8 57.105 . 9475.00 oS• $142.51 osearaThiteall 4 Meeting Meeting wif AU, re: Order IL 57.105 ... . 145.89 • 0.3 $127.59 0608/2020 AU Review • Reviewed 57:105 demand and proposed motion lot . - .• genetion Si75.00 0.2 88800 • '-' • owiorzozo OW Various ' 1 • Reviewed notice of change of attorney, re: dirk; . • ailed end spoke ye/ new counsel Cynthia dustia - mc• - nn. .. r w 'n . .. 9.3 iti•to '.... 0612312020 OW Various. Reviewed Pts letter refusing to voliiiitariai diimiss amended complaint desplte57.105 demand: called and spoke ver client, re: Prs refusal 8 next steps . . $425.00 • ' 1.0 ... .. $42581 CA/ArolarlDNXIMI BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERIC 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735477 ajar* .. D0/ :.; g.init..- sem pier copy off, letter refusing to distnes.s - • . . I .$42.• so el $42.50 06/20/2020 . • .. . . . ' - •, . Reviewed lest telueing to dismiss Count /Men. 5475.00 0.1 $4700 • 0701/2020. - - .- -• . . • • . OW . . • - Vedette 'Spoke w/ dent..re., Mengel 57.105fnotion for:. . fees/sand:lona; filed motion for attorneys' fees baSecli Pie failure to voluntarily dismiss • . " amended complaint count 1 • - i •• U2500 ' - : . .. 05 $212.50 07/021$020 OW -E: Email to lilid i re: affidavit and summary judgment. - $40• 130. .1• $42.50 7 8h020 OW . : T . : :: . • - Elis**... 0.9 1, ^1.d.r,•fti-^i.an0 ,5^9 Motionfcw. Summry Jtrdgrirrut aria MSJ evidence" • 070012020 . AU Tinconsimes, . . • Discussed ;11 Client draftinwandfifing Motion for Summary Judgment and MSJ evidence • • •••• . la An . . .. ."— . eA,ac i, - , .- 7 —. , . 07/1012020 ... : . • DW - Draft Created 1st draft of Aronberg Affidavit shared w/ . . 10cienl $425.00 07/10/2220• f AU Various ' Reviewed draft affidavit and discussed wr DAW 0.3. ' $142.50 07.1102020' .. OW Discuseed draft affidavit w/ AU kaket,4. 60 0.2 - ' 58500 07/10020 .64,41 Review • .• Reviewed Firs Request to Produce, re: • $425.00 . O1 $42.50 07/1312020. DW Teleconference Spoke yr/ Clerics counsel. re: Request ., 5425.00 0.2 ses.qo 0)!2)!2020 OW Review Reviewed PIS Amended Request Clerk. ' . . 5425.00 01 $42.50 0M7/2020 OW Teleconferen ce , Spoke w/ Clerk's counsel equest to Produce • S425.00 0.1 $42.50 07/28/2020 • OW Draft Revised Aronberg $425.00 0.5 $21250 07/21/2020 . DW Draft Finalized Aronberg Affidavit and sent to diem $425.00 0.5 $212.50 Of/29/2020 OW ' Research & Preparation Research and prep for Motion for Summary Judgment .00 1.0 . $425.00 07/30/2020 DW Various Received executed Arenberg Affidavit . $425,00 0;1 : • . $4240. 07/30/2020 OW Draft Began drifting Motion for Summary Judgment $425:00 .2.0 . se,so.o6 0805/2020 OW Draft Continued drafting Motion for Summary Judgment $42500 1.0 $425.00 08/07/2020 OW Review • Reviewed email from Plaintiff attempting to set hearing on 57.105 motion for fees/sanchons $425.00 0.1 $42.50 08/1012020 Ow Amil Sent responsive email to Pis counsel ' • $425.00 ' 0.1 $42.50 08/17/2020 Discussed . . draft MSJ iv/ AU $405.00 02 $8500. . 08/4 /2020 r i5 seneus Reviewed draft MSJ and met w/ DAW to discusS $475.00 0.5 $207.50 08/1 Draft Finalized Motion for Summary Judgment; filed yv/ coon along With Aronberg affidavit $425.00 2.0 $eso.go 08/27/2020 W Teleconference Spoke wr Clerics counsel, re: request to produce) . $425.00 0.1 $42.50 09/002020 OW various Reviewed Ks email and accepted conference call liwite for 9/2/20 . $425.00 .0.1 $48$0 0coov2020 . ; .• Ow Review • . RevieWed Clerk's response to request for . „ .:. : $; 25.60. : . 02 sa”i? ._ 09/02/2020 OW • • TeleConterenee .Spokecvd3.ft 'steins/O. ri: dispute as to whether MSJ ahead be heard before 57.105 fee motion or " vis versa • call was Unsuccessful . $4?5.00 • • • 0.5 $212.50 CNArcriberg.)OOO.3%5 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735478 '09/90020 AU Meeting '0040 w/ DAW.Phorie Cal 41.Phs counsel . : $475.80 0.2 $9500 0092/?020 OW Meeting discussed vr/ AU phone Cal Ver pyi counsel 144,00 0.2 ... 585.00 • - 09116,2020; OW E-mail . Reviewed email from pri counsel requested : ' . Arenberg to withdraw sancliOnilmelion who . *. . - - .: $4400 .Prejudice • al $42.50 09/17/2020 : DW Meebng Oiscussed wr AU filing motion ler Qat' *. $42.50 09'1 7/2020. . AU Meeting Oiscussed wl)AW Mop motion for cmp .. .. .. .. -$475.00 '. . 0.1 $47.50 090wi020.: .'• ... • OW ' Various ' . . . - • • .•°eat•led add filed id aa! daaa rdadad" , : • Conference; re: MSJ let or Erie hearing 1st . • .. • . :." .. 'ali t. ......r. .. .0 . . .• iiii?-ja• .. ... .:. . .„.• . :. 09/1812020 : OW -• .N. E-mail . Responded to Prs 9/16/20 coe/ imp riduSed to ' Wittat .1057 5 Motion; provided copy of motion to . set CAC and available dates for hearing •$425.00 ,. • • • • ' 09/19/2020 • OW E-mail . . . Rev awed Prs email insisting that 57.105 motion be withdrawn $4^ -4S y . 0.1 • $42.00. .. . 08.19,2090 OW E-mail . '. .response. Repried IC his counsel Viol tho 57.105 motion for sanctions will not be vrithdrawri end asking ter . 1 re: CMC $4 01. 142-59 08/192020 DW E-mail Sent client copy of email exchange w/ Pts coUnSel; Wet and spoke w/ Client $426.00 • • •- 0.5 $212.50 .. 09r222020 . OW • Various 0ndled and filed Notice of Heanng 1 up Court Call; spoke w/ client. co. • 0000 0.7 9297.50 fwoireozo DW - Review Reviewed Prs Memo of Law °pooling• $425 .00 57.105 motion for lees/sanctions )," 0.7 $297.50t wpm 20 DW Review Reviewed Rrs Response to Aron erg's request to schedule 57. tO5 motion (Or lees after MSJ • $425.00 0.5 ' $212.$0 10.'022020 ' El • Review Reviewed Pr Memo ol‘aliv Opposing 57.105 motion ' "' '. ' .* :. .9475.00 0.5 • " 37 $2 .50 1022/2020 . AU ReView Reviewed nee to Arenberg% fecluest to Schedule 57) motion after MSJ . pm .® 0.4 $190.00 10/12/2020 OW Research Research caselaw 5 statutes. re: spona to Prs response Memo °I Law $425:00 1.0 $425,00, 1093/2020 DW Research Analyze Continued researching casetaw, re: response to Prs memo of law $421.00 1.0 $425.00 10/132020 OW Created 1st draft 01 Response to Prs Memo of law and shared w/ Chant • $42500 4.0 $1,700.0.0 Koran o ciii: r, ? Discussed w/ AU caselaw and draft response to memo $425.00 0.5 $212.50 ,.. ,10/13/2020 Maui Reviewed draft MSJ. discussed draft wl OAW and caselaw $475.00 0.7 $338.50 • 10/14/2020 Or00 Fi nalized and tiled Response to Prs Memo of Law $4$00 ' 1.0 $42.900 10114/2020 ; OW Telephone • . Spoke w/ chant. re: memo of lay .... $42800 . 0.2 $atao 10/14/2020 OW -. TelepiiOne . SpOke w/ client again re:±eeponselo memo of kw ie..25:00. • 0:1 $44.50 . . ... _ 10/I aretrepr .. — . • "•••. .:.Dr. ' ' . Attend Hestia • Ali:lea Mese* ie. Weal to Set CAC: east? • ' . ' . • - . ' ' • ...,-- --, ' ' '' ; 7....sessou 17.5. • • • • —:.:..6637,50 .. .. . len 502020 OW ReVierntd Chia end finer Wien ill; re: sitOeiniiii. Various . ' $42 0.00` " i . 0..p Sent copy to Client Soil called to in ' • . . i • • 1932.59 CA/Arongerp000,38e1 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735479 10/152020 OW Telephone . Spoke wl Pt's counsel, re: settlement $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/152020 OW Telephone Spoke w/dient, re: Prs settlement proposal $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/15/2020 AU Various Attended hearing, re: motion to set CMC; discussed w/ client $475.00 1.0 tA75.00 10/15/2020 AU Various Discussed Pt's settlement proposal w/ DAW and then ve/ Cienl $475.00 0.4 $19000 10/15/2020 DW Meeting Discussed Prs settlement proposal w/ AIJ $425.00 0.2 585.00 10/16/2020 OW Various Drafted and shared Proposed order wl Pea counsel 3425.00 0.5 $212.50 .10/1602020 OW Telephone Spoke w/ Pt's counsel, re: settlement $425.00 0.2 585.00 10/16/2020 DW Telephone Spoke w/dient, re: Rs settlement proposal $425.00 • 0.5 $212.50 10/16/2020 DW Meeting • . Discussed Prs settlement proposal w/ AU $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/16/2020 AU Meeting . Discussed Pt's settlement proposal ve/ DAW $475.00 02 $95.00 OW Various Uploaded proposed order, re: CMC for Judge Harder 0.1 $42.50 10/19/2020 DW Telephone Spoke client, re: Ins settlement proposal ''... $42$.00 0.2 $85.00 10/19/2020 DW Telephone Spoke w/ Rs counsel, re: settlement / ...- -_..7z.,,, - $425.00 0.1 • $42.50 10/19/2020 AU Meeting Discussed Prs settlement pr w/ DA y 5475.00 0.2 $95.00 10/19/2020 OW Meeting Discussed Pt's settlement propose/OW AD, ,, \ V $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/20/2020 DW Various Reviewed email from PI, re settlehiontlient /copy to Client and called to discuSs 'k.. $425.00 0.5 $212.50 10/20/2020 OW Telephone Spoke w/dient re: settlement $425.00 0.4 $170.00 10/20/2020 OW Telephone Spoke w/ Pt's cmiretipl, re: Seelleenent $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/20/2020 DW Telephone Spoke w/ die*, re: salriment $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/20/2020 OW Meeting - F Discussed Preeettlement proposal w/ AIJ $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10202020 AU Meeting Distriiesses Prs settlement proposal w/ DAW $475.00 0.2 $95.00 1021/2020 OW Various $425.00 .r,. Dratted ithefiled Motion to Set Hewing on Aron$rg MSJ; dratted proposed Order granting Motion to set: checked court availability: emaied Pis counsel, ro: choose dale for hearing 1.0 $425.00 loniano OW ..Review y -,✓ Reviewed Order, re: CMC unnecessary $425.00 0.1 $42.50 1021/2020 DW $ephone ''' Spoke wl client, re: media response $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/21/2020 OW_ . Telephone Spoke w/ client, re: media response $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/21/2920 OW Telephone Spoke w/ client. re: media response $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/21/2020 OW Telephone Spoke w/ client, re: media response $425.00 0.1 542.50 1021/2020- OW Telephone Spoke w/ client, re: media response $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10;21/2020 OW E•mai Sent emai w/ Aronbem statement to media $425.00 0.1 $42.50 1021/2020 AL) Meeting Discussed media response iv/ DAW $475.00 0.3 $142.50 10/21/2020 OW Meeting Discusses) media response w/ AU $425.00 0.3 - $127.50 . „ _ 10/22/2020 OW Various Reviewed Prs•Notice of Drooping Aronberg as -- - - party; spoke w/ Client and AU, re: notice and next steps - - l - •• $425.00 0.5 .: .. _ ... ._ $212.50 CA/AroftenD902t1071 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735480 • Reviewed Pi's Notice of Dropping Aronbetg.ps .-.1.. . ■ VariouS party: spoke wf CI:ent and DAW, re: notiatiliiillit $475.00 0.5 . $237.66 .10/22/2020 .... .. slops . ; • ,SP ,eaos Totals: Mao Entry Sub-Total: $awn) SublTotal: $32,140116 TOW 532:441.00; AMMO CA/AroBiliMIDOPMag BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 4:10:49 PM EFTA02735481