Court Records
••••• • . .4' • . fl:`. 46 fr. • .t.`i • • • • „: • . • •••:- . • • • • . • .• . GEittiviay Blvij • e'••• • • '• • Jacobs Scholz & Wyler, LLC Perparslina Sitagh,•pc 12O4 Uriftefi SiMei . • •904:26144a ,.) ' • ••'• • • • .• '. • :. .• . , • • • • • , • • • •••• ' .••• • • A • • I. • - ealafice • 532,440.00 : ••• 1„ • • • jiivolcii. ; ' • . • • Date. Payittiitit Te 'Due:bib; • • . • Arenberg (SAOS) ad v. CA. loriclit Holding; LLC . • • , • • ' 1.•• . • . ' • • .. . • Time•EritriOs • • • . ", • , ' Reb Hours Uris TOW 11/254019 Review initial review of summons se o)tn asztoi • 1.5 . *63740 11/254019 OW Review Reviewed motion for pro bac ;WI and Judge . Halela order granting 5425.00 . • 0:2 •• - $95.00 11/213/2019 ' OW Teleconference Teteconterenee w/ Client, re: response to lawsuit • $425.00 • 0.5. ' s212.,59 tuzelia.19' OW Draft ' Drafted engagement letter and sent to client $425,00 0.3 . 1- $127.50. 11/26/2019 OW Review . Rail .. 15tlittuit local Wet $421.00 ' 1 A Vszi.66. .. 11/26/2019 AU Review complaint ' ..D4t5.00.) ' ' 1.0 $475.00 11/242019 Au Meeting Meeting vie DAW IC CliSf:USI lawsuit and strategy . . . .45?• ° 9 0.5 • 523730 11/26/2019. OW Meeting Meeting w/ AU to discuss lawsuit and strategy .. .0 25.0 OD. $21150 11/264619 . AU Telenonfer›,A Teleconference wi Client, re: response to lawsuit , $475.00 ' ' 0.5 .1437.43 12/02/2019 0,W ., . . tihon a . Research and peep for Motion to dismiss $425.00 2.0 585020 12/02)2019 at c:r iscanft • 1st Draft motion to dismiss . • $425.00' • 1.0 5425.00 12/02/2019 .ference Teleconference w/ Client, re: draft motion to dismiss $425.00 o. 5212,50 )2/022019 : AU Review Reyievied 1st Draft MTDismiss • $475.00 -0.3 .. ' -$142,5ti, 12422019 'AU Teleconference Telecanference w/ ciierd. to: dial! motion lo 'aunts; , . .. - . . $475.00 • - ; • 0.5 • ' • ' $237.50 .. • . . 12103/2019 . AU Meeting Meeting w/ DAM re: motion to cismili . . ..., • • $475.00 .. 4.12 '595.00 12/054019 OW . Meettrig • Meeting w/ AO. re: MTDisniss ' • - 7-sizi.bii. fr.' .. 02 . - .135 00 14/(1812019 . ' • . • . qv., 542 - . , Completed I:Wald/an of rrialionto dismiss: WM . .0i "C . •5.0Court . ' 0.7 . si,97 50 1206,24:119. OV4 Teleednietentges Spoke wicaent, n: final draft ot motion to citsreitS $.425.4). ; b.5 •• 5212.50 Party JOINT ID#. J24 EVaLf GATE ADMITtE 0: 11/64202 2 Can No 2019-CA.014W /OSEPH MMUZ20 CLERK CA/AroBlIERPOle BEACH COUNTY, FL, KSSEICMIrOZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM [ Joint Exhibit J24 EFTA02735109 12%082019 cm .yo•donigioiie Spoke witClerk's eternity; re: response. ..- - ' 54.125.6 - •: ' 9.5 . - .- $212.50 nio•ipotp Reviewed final draft lifrOismiss •"... $47540. '595.00 1203/2019 ", AU Review ''..' "... Reviewed Clerk's PoTrOisniiSS . • - $475.60' ..7' 02 . • $ii.cii 12/13thens DW. , .. • . Reviewed Clerk's Motion to Dismiss i 4.26)4 $212.50 01/1872020 .' DW . filevienv Reviewed Order Setting Hearing on Defendants' • Mrc iar4fis S425.00; al ' $42.50 01/1872010. OW Reirieir . Reirterweel =bon for pro hat vice 5425-.00 9.1 $42.50 01/112020 . Din Review ReVieivria Pre Amended Complaint • $425.06 - . 'Ili; t s'asloo 61/i 7/2020 OW Teledoriference tookeeettiollentIeljimended Complaint 5425,00 A . .521250 01/172020 . .OW Review Revering Pre nOticeolfifing .• &pate . 1, :•.'. • 542.50. 01/20/2020 . AU ; Review Reviewed Pie Ati Sid $475 .0. . . . . . $11250 01/21/2020 • .DW Review' Reviewed Judge Mines Order Cancelling MTDismiss Hearing -$O . ‘..... 0.1 • 542 50 01/21/2020 '. OW . .. Review Reviewed Pis Objection to Defendants' MTDismiss $4 ' oz.. • . IS.® [Phone Redacted] , OW ' Teleconference Spoke with client. re: Amended complaint . iii ]..6o .0.5 • .i 1;.56 012172020 . ' AU Meeting Meeting w/ DAM re: response to Am. • 5475.00 • 0.2 .$95..00 01/21/2020 OW Meeting Meeting w/ AU. re: response to Anirepl. 5425.00 0.2 118.00 01/22/2020 . , OW .Review Renewed Order granting pro hat iiA.Tedt) .• . 5425 00 0.1 . . $42.50 01/22/2020 OW" Research & Draft , Researched and drafted re se to Amended complaint $425.00 .1.0 $425.00 01/23/2020 DW Teleconference Spoke with Clerk's alto re. ponse to - • amended cornplaiN . $425.00 02 sis.00 01/24/2020 OW venous Compieted Answer/MTDismiss Amended filed with Court: sent copy to Client $42500 1.0 . 14'15.00Complaint 01/24/2020 OW Draft Drafted and Red Notice of Unavailability $425.00 . 0.4 $170.00 01/24/2020 AU Review "Reviewed final Answer/MTDismiss 5475.00 0.2 $95.00 01/27/2020 DW Revise Reviewed Clerk's Answer/MTDismiss sa25.® 0.3 5127.50 02/0372020 • OW. Review , Reviewed Order seeks) hearing on Des' MTDismiss . 5425.00 01 . $42.50 02/0312020• OW Ttar hSepoatikengt.fient. chre2: order soetting MTDismiss 5425.00 0.5. 1212.50 03/13/202 40 , Reviewed Prs Opposition to Arenberg MTOismiss & Clerk's MTDismiss 5425.00 • 1i $837.50 03/13/2020 Sew Reviewed Prs Opposition to Arenberg MTOismiss & Clerk's IATDisrriss . 5475.00 0.7 $332.50 03/18/2020 Teleconference • •• . Reviewed email from Prs counsel, re: motion to continue hearing S425.00. 0.1 542.50 03/18/2020 OW Review Reviewed RI's unopposed motion for continuance . S425.06 ''. 0.1 . siso 031184020" . -. • . • Emads yr/ Clerk's counsel, re: Pis request to continue hearing . .. . • 5425.00 - - • • - 0.2 . . •• . •.' WOO . . [Phone Redacted]. DW .' • 8 I Reviewed email from Pl, re: agreed order& .. . . responded . . f125.00 0.1 . . . , '. 142.51 03/2072020' DW Review Reviewed Court's agreed order continuing hearing $25.00 . 0.1 • • • ' $aiso CA/Arcitilf.09034)4 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM EFTA02735110 04/21/2020 OW Review Revihwed order rescheduling hearing on Del( MTDismiSs 5425 00 0.1 $42.50 04/21/2020 DW Teleconference SP°N''''' i diem. re: cider. rescheduling ge.Pirin Meting for June 3.2020 $425.00 03 $127,50 04/21/2026 `r Al) Review Reviewed Order reschedueung.MTDisinish hrsiiiihi . ' $47S.00 0.1 .. • So • : . 0502020 ... OW Review Reviewed order setting Zoom hewing, rt ' '. . ... SATDismiSS . •. . . - . $42.5.00 • .• 0.1. • : S4.0 . 45i22:/202.13. DW • Teleconference .. Spoke w/ Client, it 1?Oiriniicfill lie yla porn .. • $425.00 • • • 02 585.00 osrzypoiO :OW Review - Reviewed Clerk's fifin6 change of any el recdrd ' ' $ozsio .1 $szso Siaitooio . OW Teleconfaitrie" Spokes..1W elerliS new counsel. Nicol(Fingisehist • $425.00 58500 Oiriatiozo DW E-mail Reviewed Pts email, re: cases and euthoritiet tot MTOIsmiss hearing; responded . • $425. -C.71)1 542.50 05129/2020 Ow Prepasation . Began oral argument prep for'EA3MThismiss .. : hearing • .1.0' - • :: ." 25.00 • . : . . .. • 06/01/2020 :. OW E-mail Reviewed email from Judge Marx's JR and . responded . • 0.1 $4a:So 05431/2020 DW , venous Reviewed PIS 500+ page binder, re: MT V: .'prepped for hearing 1425a ' 3.0 $1.273.00 0602/2020 • • - • • ... , . OW --- • E-rnal • - • Dra email to Drafted and sent client. re. 0 tomorrow sois.00 o.i .50 • 66,03/2020 OW AtientHitaring , Prepped for and attended MT , via zoom . S425.00 14 . !also 06/03/2020 ' DW Teleconference • Spoke Withnf, re. ss hearing 5425.00 0.5 $232.50 06/03/2020 OW E-mail Envifiecteourtetc Of ronberg's Answer and - • • •MTDismisi dge ... 5425.00 • 0.1 $42.50 0903/2020 • DW E-mail d2 lefrom Client and replied 5425.00 0.1. $42.50 06/03/2020 AU Attend Hearing resi hearing via Zoom $475.00 1.6 $475.00 06/03/2020 , . AU Review Reviessilfhirder granting NODismiss w/ prejudice . $475.00 0.3- $142.59 00/08/2020 OW Review Courts Order Granting Defendants Count II wl Prejudice • + • $42500 . OS . $212.50Dismiss 'OW V • Shared order w/ Caen, and spoke wr. re: result and •06436/2020 plan going lonvard, re: 57.105 3425.00 0.5 . • .321240 Researched § 57.105 Fla. Slat.; drafted 57.105 demand letter and proposed motion, for attorney( . lees/sanctions; Served RI's counsel with demand letter and proposed motion. • . . . $4' 25.00 . • 2.0 51350.00 Naral4 Meeting Meeting w/ DAVY. re:Order & 57.105 1475.00 : . 0.3' $142.50 ostoorzozo w kiekeig Meeting w/ AIJ. re: Order & 57.10‘.. .4 2.5.40 . 0.3 Si27.50 00/00/2020 AU • Review Reviewed 57.105 demand slid proposed motionkm: sartdion . . 5475.00 ' 05100. 600/2020 .....„........ . . OW • • . Vahous • • .. • Reviewed noires el change' Shawn's).. M: Cork; . • celled and spoke winew Cotinsitcynthia Geed& .. . . • . ' . , . • Wile . . • 06/23/2020 OW ..: . •• Vat Reviewed Pis letter refining to vokintarihr csiness :' amended complaint despite 51.1os &imams...cad end spoke w/ client, re: or Mimi! B next Steps . ' • • 5425.90. . -' ' . .. .. • ". - 1,0 • .tit&ock CAlArcrigES9,101 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM EFTA02735111 /1 - . . • .. ... 1:01/20/2.024? .. ... D. W.4.2 • E -Sent client copy of Pis letter refusing to cfismiss confiMint:••: • -...----..- ' • . .....s it sjo 0.1 542.50 0523/2020, ... ..: AU ''•, , .. , .. Revew • . . .. . . , . . .. .. • . .. . . Reviewed.Pre tenet (eloping to dismiss Count' VArn. $475.00. 0.1 247.50 02414020 / : . . . Various Spoke Ve/ diem; re: filing of 57.105 motion for . . feesisarictionS; filed motion for attorneys' tees • based on R's failure to voluntarily dismils .'. arriended'complaint count 1 ' • • . . . ' " $4i 5.00 •• . . 0.5 . 5212.58 87/024611 , VW. , E.mail Email to Chant, re affidavit angsurniMayjudginent • 5425.60 . .. I' • .12.50, • oppoi$620 Telecofil,fic! . sting . . . Discusso vd Client Ongdpia and Motion foe. ' Si; • ."' *lament and MSJ eVicience ‘ 42.5.06 " • • • ... ... $297:56, 07/084020 ' AU • • Teleconference Diseased w/ Ghent drafting and filing Motion for Sumrn acy '.14i8gment-and 18SJ evitlence . • . • 1175.00 - • ' • ' 533150 0//i0/20120. DV/ Draft Created 1st draft of Aronberg Affidavit; shared w/ dent . . - 1.0. $425.00 07/10/2020orio2p : AU Varloui Reviewed draft affidavit and dim:iamb:I v DAW .il 0.3 $14250 .07i104820 • •• OW. Meeting Oiscusied draft affidavit wl AIJ .00 02; - 985.00 07/j3/2020 .. OW Review Reviewed Pfs Request to Produce; re: Chi .00 0.A. 1250 07/134020. OW Teleconference Spoke kier Clerk's counsel, re: Request,* $425.00 0.2 *woo 07/274020 DW Review iftekfiawed Pr s Amended Request .. Ca*: S!.125:00 0.1 $42.50 07/274020 OW Teleconference . . - eitiClerlficouheel Soblt : ' 10 • $425.00 OA . $42.50 07/28/2920 OW Draft ReinseCiArosib 2A, .avi . 2.42s.op 0.5 $21250 07/23/2020 . OW Draft Finalized Atikh A and sent to client - $425.00 0.5 $21250 07128/2020 OW Research & Preparation Resew. I Motion for Summary J t ' W5:90 1.0 . $425.00 07/30/2020 OW Various sjouted Aronberg Affidavit $425.00 0.1 • ,542.50 • 07/30/2020 - OW Draft Began drafting Motion for Summary Judgment 12100 2.0 . $850.00 08105/2020 OW Draft Continued drafting Motion for Summary Judgment 5425.00 1.0 5425.00 08/074020 DW Review . Reviewed email from Plaintiff attempting. to set hearing .on 57.105 motion for lees/sanctions 125.00 0.1 • ' .842.50 08/10/2020 OW .6/nail Sent responsive email to Pfs counsel 5425.00 0.1 542.50 1917/2020 OW Meeting Discussed draft MSJ w/ AU 125.00 0.2. Snob. 08/174020 AU Various Reviewed draft MSJ and met w/ DAW to tines $475.00 0.5 $237.50 08/1 OW Draft . . . Finalized Motion for Summary Judgment; feed Yei coon along with Aronberg affidavit 12520 2.0 toso.oti. 0847/2020 W Teleconference Spoke wr Clerk's counsel. re: request to produce $425.00 0.1 $42.50 09/01/2020 OW • Various Reviewed Pfs email and accepted conferefice eal invite for 90J20 12500 .01 1 2,59 09/22020 ....,.- . . . .. . - OW . Rev Reviewed Clerk's response to request for. .. . $42i .00 .. . iii' • si s.00 09/02/2029 OW • ... Tabor SPolcilyi P.I's counsel, re: dispute-ea to whether. 1.4SJ shdad be heard 57.105 fee motion or _. -viayersa • cal was unsuccessful . Si125.90 0.5 • • . ... - ' 821259 - CA/AroNBWOB03Be BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM EFTA02735112 4 09/024020 AU : Meeting Discussed w/ DAW phone c.illi// PrefieUrf.sel . . -•••:Te176.00 0.2 30640. 09/102/2020 . .... ., OW '' ' . . Meeting - . Discussed wi AUpile. necal.WiPTeCouniet. a:' .-;..4405.04 0.2 st4tio 09/10/2020 .. . OW . Semi Reviewed email froth .PSS counsel requested Arenberg to withdraw sanctionemolion w/o . . prejudice • - $425.00 • 0.1 $42.50. 09/17/2020 OW • Meeting Discussed w/ AU tiling motion for CMC ' • $415.-°6 01. .$42.50 09/..1.7.4020. AU lAtieling Discussed w/ DAW Sling motion for CMC ''• / ' $47400 0.1 $4750 ... .. , ; oiv.faroal DW Varietts ,. • •/.Drafted and tiled motion.to set case management Conference; re: MSJ 1st Or Fee hearing 1st ......, . . ‘ 42.5 00 . : v . • 0.5 $212.50 000 92020 •' OW E -real Responded to Prs 9/16/20 email end refused tor''' . withdraw 57.105 motion; provided copy el/notion to Set CMC'and aVallable dates for hearing • . • • $425.00 , A . • . 0.1 $42.50 $42.50. . ... . • .. 09/42020 ' OW. 6-mad . Reviewed Prs email insisting that 57.105moticn be $4. osvisnogo • • OW - . E-mal Reified to Pt's counsel That the 57.105 Motion for sanctions wilt not be withdrawn and asking for response, re: CMC 54 0.1 $42.50 09n812020 • DW 'E-mail Sent client copy of email exchange w/Prs • called and spoke w/ Client . .• gagg.aci . - 04 • $212.50 • 09122/2030 DV/ Various Dratted and filed Notice of Heating 1 up Court Call: spoke w/ client, re • 5425.0D 0.7 • szpi.so 0/02/2020 OW • Review. Reviewed Prs Memo of Law 57.105 motion for fees/sanctions • $425.00 0.7 "$287.50 CM Review Reviewed Prs Response to Arisiberge request b10/02/2020 schedule 57.105 motion for lees after MSJ ' • 642500 0.5 $i12.50 . - • - 10/07J2020 AU • • " Review Reviewed mo COLaw apposing 57.05 ' : motion.' • .54j 5.00 ' 0.5 . • .. $237.50 . - 10/02/2020 AU Review Reviewr ed P Response to Aronderr(s feepelit tO . schedule 57.105 moron after MSJ um® OA $19000 10/12/2020 DW Research Research caselaw & statutes, rei response to PM . Memo of Law ' • $425.00 . 1.0 $42.5.00 . 1013/2020 DW e‘ • R search Analyze . Continued researcring caselaw, re: response to . Ks memo of taw . ta m; 1.0 $425.00 • 413/2020 OW i lt x Created 1st draft of Response to Prs Memo ot Law and shared w/ Client S42400 4.0 $1.700.00 . . motion . n e. Discussed w/ AIJ caselaw and draft response to memo • • • $425.00 0.5 $212.50 10113/21 111.4aflous Reviewed draft MSJ, eiscussed draft w/ DAVI and caselaw • .". $475.00 0.7 • $332.50 10/14/2020 Draft. Finalized and filed Response to Prs Memo of Law $425,00 • t.0 • ' $425.00 1014/2020 ' . OW Telephone Spoke w/ client. re: memo of law $426.00 .0.2 585.00 10142020 OW fel/Phone Spoke cal client again. re: response to memo of law $42500 0.1 $4240 101;52020 ' .. ..-. OW • ,. . Altend Hearing --dent Attended hearing, re: Motion il), Sal CMG. ; called fo discuss • . $425.g9„ ., ,_. , ,, .$63.7,50_ . .: .: 10/152.020 . OW . • Various Reviewed email and letter frOm PE re: settlement. Sent copy to Client end calked to discuis. • . ...00. 0.5 . . . • '5212.50 CA/AroBlid0)0090304 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM EFTA02735113 r‘. 10/15/2020 DW Telephone Spoke w/ Pi's counsel, re: settlement $425.00 0.1 . $42.50 10/192020 DW Telephone Spoke w/ client, re: Prs settlement propose' $425.00 0.2 . $85.00 1915/2020 AU - Various - Attended heating, re: motion to set CMC: discussed w/ client. $475.00 1.0 $47500 10/192020 AU Various Oiscusied Pis settlement proposal w/ DAW and then w/Ckent $475.00 0.4 $190.00 10/15/2020 DW Meeting Discussed Prseettlement proposal sr/ AU $423.00 0.2 585.00 10/16/2020 OW Various Drafted and Shared proposed order w/ Prs counsel $425.00 0.5 $212.50 10/16/2020 OW Telephone • Spoke iv/ Ks counsel, re: settlement $425.00 . 40.2 - , $85.00 10/16/2020 OW Telephone Spoke-w/ client, te: Prs settlement proposel $425.00 4,,j1.5 $212.50 10/16/2020 OW Meeting. Discussed Prs settlement proposal w/ AU $425.00 ,... 0.2 585.00 1916/2020 AU Meeting DiscusSed Prs settlement proposal w/ DAW sto.s.op 0.2 $95.00 10/192020 DW Various Uploaded proposed order. re: CMC for Judge Hereto -. i _ 442; 5.00 ---- 0.1 $42.50 10/19/2020 DW Telephone ../c Spoke w/ client, re: Pt's settlement proposal l,;•,„„, $425.00 0.2 585.00 10/192020 OW Telephone Spoke w/ Pi's counsel. re: settlement Aeomisikk $425.00 . 0.1 $42.50 10119/2020 AU Meeting Discussed Pis settlement proposal w/ DA 5475.00 0.2 595.00 10/19/2020 OW Meeting Discussed Pis settlement propose:4p^ $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/20/2020 OW Venous Reviewed email from Pl. re: settte*aivcopy to Client and called to dispk‘s .), 1pp 5425.00 0.5 $212.50 1020/2020 OW ' Telephone Spoke w/dient, re: settlitrek $425.00 - 0.4 $170.00 10292020 OW Telephone Spoke w/ Prs co1smic& re: 01)ilernent 5425.00 0.1 $42.50 10.20/2020 OW Telephone Spoke w/ lied. re: sekkoment $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/202020 OW Meeting Discussed PfsetIllement proposal w/ AU $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/20/2020 AU Meeting Dia:eased Pfs Settlementproposal w/ DAW $475.00 , 0.2 $95.00 1021/2020 DW Various Drafted 30 /filed Motion to Set Hearing on Arenberg Mme: dratted proposed order granting melee to set checked court availabikly; °mailed Pi's counsel, re: choose date for hearing 5425.00 1.0 $425.00 1021/2020 OW -21 Review Reviewed Order, re: CMC unnecessary 5425.00 0.1 542.50 1021/2020 OW Telephone Spoke wl client, re: media response $425.00 0.2 $85.00 10/21/2020 DiAl c .:Teheoleene Spoke w/ client, re: media response $425.00 0.1 $42.50 1021/2020 . OW Telephone Spoke wi dient re: media response $425.00 0.1 $42.50 1021/2020 DW Telephone Spoke w/ client. re: media response $425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/21/2020''- DW Telephone Spoke w/ client, re: media response 5425.00 0.1 542.50 10/212020 OW E-mai Sen1 email w/ Aronberg statement to media 5425.00 0.1 $42.50 10/21/2020 AIJ Meeting Discussed media response wt 0Aw $475.00 0.3 $142.50 10212020 OW Meeting Discussed media response w/ AU $425.00 0.3 $127.50 - -- . • 10/22/2020 • • -- DW Various Reviewed Prs Notice of Dropping Aroneerg as • - party; spoke w/ Client and AU, re: notice and next steps $425.00 _ ._ .. 0.5 .. . ... . .... . . $212.50 CA/ArcUntigivil000300 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM EFTA02735114 Reviowed Pl's Notice of Dropping Aronberg as ;la/22/2020 AU Various • ‘ • • pot"; Woke vet Client and DAW, re: notice and next $475.00 0.5 $237.50 Totals: 74.8 $32,440.00 rime Entry Sub-Total: Sub-Total: $32.440.00 $32,440.00 TOW: $32.440.00 $0.00 $32,440.00 CA/Arctild0p000a0G1 BEACH COUNTY, FL, ABRUZZO, CLERK. 3/27/2023 3:44:22 PM EFTA02735115